Advertisement IC Markets

Second-Peak Momentum Check: Filtering M5 Double Tops With RSI and Candle Size

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1693
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Second-Peak Momentum Check: Filtering M5 Double Tops With RSI and Candle Size

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

Double tops on M5 are common and many of them fail. One filter that is easy to test is whether momentum weakened on the second peak.

Two simple measures:
  • RSI divergence: the second peak makes a similar or higher price high while RSI(14) makes a lower high.
  • Candle size: the average body of the last three candles into the second peak is smaller than into the first.
A test setup:
  • Peaks within a set distance of each other (e.g. 0.3 × ATR).
  • Entry on a close below the neckline.
  • Stop above the higher of the two peaks.
  • Compare results with and without the momentum filter.
The filter usually cuts the number of trades considerably. Whether it improves expectancy depends on the pair and session, which is exactly why it is worth testing rather than assuming.

Do you use any momentum confirmation on double tops or bottoms, and has it improved results?
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Second-Peak Momentum Check: Filtering M5 Double Tops With RSI and Candle Size

Post by Shadow Trader »

I tested the candle size filter on EURUSD M5 during London and it cut more noise than the RSI one. RSI(14) divergence shows up all through a steady trend on that timeframe, so alone it let in plenty of tops that were only pauses.

I also added a minimum gap of 8 bars between peaks. Two highs three candles apart are usually one consolidation rather than two attempts, and those failed most often in my sample.
img_13735_r1.png
img_13735_r1.png (65.95 KiB) Viewed 105 times
The illustration shows a setup passing everything: peaks at 1.1684 and 1.1685 eleven bars apart, RSI 86 then 73, and bodies into the second high about a third the size. Entry is the close at 1.1670 under the 1.1672 neckline, stop at 1.1688.

That stop is the weak spot. It is 18 pips when the average M5 bar there is about 4, so on some trades I now wait for a neckline retest and put the stop above the retest high.

The trade count dropped from about 140 setups over six months to under 50. I would not read much into expectancy until it has a few more months behind it.

Has anyone tried the same filter on double bottoms in New York? I suspect the candle size part behaves differently there.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Second-Peak Momentum Check: Filtering M5 Double Tops With RSI and Candle Size

Post by Shadow Trader »

The peak tolerance in the test setup is tighter than it looks. On EURUSD M5 in London the ATR is often around 4 pips, so 0.3 times ATR allows barely more than a pip between the two highs, and plenty of genuine double tops miss that.

I widened it to 0.5 times ATR and the extra setups performed about the same as the original ones. Going to 1.0 let in too many lower highs that were really just a trend pausing.

Targets were the bigger question in my testing. The classic measured move, peak to neckline projected down, was reached on a minority of trades, while half of that distance was reached on most of them.

So I now take two thirds off at half the pattern height and leave the rest for the full projection with the stop moved to entry. On a 13 pip pattern that first exit is only 6 or 7 pips away, which is exactly why the retest entry matters, since with an 18 pip stop it would never pay.

Has anyone measured how long price takes to reach the neckline after the second peak? My impression is that slow breaks of more than 10 bars fail far more often.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Second-Peak Momentum Check: Filtering M5 Double Tops With RSI and Candle Size

Post by Shadow Trader »

RSI reads overbought above 70 and oversold below 30. On a one-minute chart, those readings flash all day, and treating each one as a reversal signal is a quick way to lose money.

In a strong move, RSI sits above 70 for long stretches while price keeps climbing. Fading it means selling into momentum. In a quiet range, RSI hovers around 50 and never gives a signal at all.

Where it does help is in divergence and in context. A failed push to a new high with lower RSI inside a well-defined range can mark exhaustion. A reading that stays pinned high can confirm that a trend is strong.

Settings matter too. The default 14 period on one-minute candles covers only fourteen minutes of data, which is very noisy. Some scalpers shorten it for sensitivity, others lengthen it for stability, and neither answer is obviously right.

The honest test is to log every RSI-based entry for a month and compare it with entries without it. If the indicator adds nothing, it's decoration.

Is RSI earning its place on the screen?
Post Reply