Advertisement IC Markets

EURJPY and the opening range break: does it still work after costs?

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
LondonScalper
Posts: 965
Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am

EURJPY and the opening range break: does it still work after costs?

Post by LondonScalper »

I've been running a simple London opening range break on EURJPY for a few months and wanted an honest cost check, not a victory lap.

Mark the first 15–30 minutes after London cash open. I only take the break if Asia was relatively contained and the first drive shows follow-through beyond a couple of noisy ticks. Entry is on a shallow retest of the broken edge, not the first spike through. Stop sits the other side of the range; target is a measured bite of the morning range, not a day-trade fantasy.

On EURJPY the move can look clean on M5 and still die once you add spread plus a bit of slip. My rule now: if average hold cost for the last twenty ORBs eats more than about a third of the median winner, I drop size or skip the pair that week. I also refuse ORB when a Japan or Euro print sits inside my expected hold window — pattern beauty does not override calendar.

I journal whether the break was continuation of Asia or a true London expansion. Those two behave differently after costs.
  • Do you still take EURJPY ORB after costs, or has it become a chart fantasy?
  • 15-minute box or 30 — what actually pays you?
Curious how others measure "still works" here without lying to the journal.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
PropScalpDesk
Posts: 521
Joined: Sat Sep 19, 2026 7:50 pm

Re: EURJPY and the opening range break: does it still work after costs?

Post by PropScalpDesk »

Your one-third rule is a good test. I'd only add that on EURJPY the cost figure needs the spread at the moment of entry, not the average. At 08:00 London the EURJPY spread on a raw account is often a pip or more before it settles, compared with a few tenths later in the morning, and ORB entries are exactly the ones that happen in that first stretch. When I measured it that way, my EURJPY ORB went from marginal to negative, and I stopped taking it.

On the box, I found 15 minutes worked better on the yen crosses, with the condition that the break has to come after 08:15. Breaks inside the box-forming period were mostly noise.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: EURJPY and the opening range break: does it still work after costs?

Post by Shadow Trader »

Spread at the moment of entry changed my numbers too, but LondonScalper's retest entry softens it more than PropScalpDesk's figures suggest. On my EURJPY log the spread averaged about 1.4 pips at 08:00 London and around 0.5 by 08:20, and retests of a 15 minute box rarely come before 08:20.
img_12448_r1.png
img_12448_r1.png (80.99 KiB) Viewed 107 times
The chart is a typical one in round numbers, with the box from 162.40 to 162.62 and the break closing at 162.70 at 08:25. The retest filled 162.64, the stop sat below the box at 162.37 and the target was 162.84, one box height above the edge.

That is 27 pips of risk for 20 of target. With 0.5 spread plus 0.4 commission the cost is under 5 percent of the winner, far from the one third line.

It bites when narrow boxes meet early fills. A 6 pip box entered on the first push at 08:16, paying about a pip of spread plus commission and some slip, loses about a third of its 6 pip target to costs.

So I would add a minimum box width rather than judge the pair as a whole. Do 30 minute boxes clear that minimum more often for anyone without the break coming too late?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: EURJPY and the opening range break: does it still work after costs?

Post by Shadow Trader »

The 27 pips of risk against 20 of target in my last example needs a win rate above about 57 percent to break even before costs. With costs it is closer to 60.

My log has 41 EURJPY retest trades from the 15 minute box. Twenty six reached the target, which is about 63 percent, so it clears the line but not by enough to relax about.

I tried a stop below the box midpoint as the alternative. On that example it would sit at 162.49, giving 15 pips of risk for the same 20 pip target.

Over the same 41 trades the midpoint stop was hit 19 times, against 15 with the full box stop, so four winners became losers. The smaller risk more than made up for that, and the average R per trade improved.

The minimum box width I would set is 15 pips. Below that the costs take too large a share of the target, and the midpoint stop gets so close that ordinary noise around the retest is enough to reach it.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: EURJPY and the opening range break: does it still work after costs?

Post by Shadow Trader »

Around 5pm New York time, the trading day rolls over. Banks settle positions, liquidity providers reset their books, and many of them pull quotes for a few minutes. Retail spreads on majors can jump from one pip to ten or more, and exotic pairs can quote spreads that look like typos.

Here is what makes this window dangerous for scalpers. Stop-losses can trigger on the widened spread even when the real market has barely moved. Take-profits on the other side can go untouched. Pending orders may fill at prices that look nothing like the chart a minute earlier.

Brokers differ in how they handle it. Some widen spreads honestly and let everything run. Some freeze trading for a few minutes. Some hold the last quote while the market moves underneath.

The simplest protection is to be flat before the window and to stay out until spreads settle, which usually takes fifteen to thirty minutes. A live spread display on the chart makes the return to normal easy to see.

The size of the blowout also depends on the pair. Majors might widen to five or ten pips for a few minutes, while crosses and exotics can widen to dozens. Brokers with variable spreads show the full effect, and those with fixed spreads may simply stop filling orders, which is a different kind of problem.

A habit that pays off is to watch the live spread on the platform during the window for a week or two without trading. Recording the time it spikes, the peak, and the time it takes to settle gives a personal schedule. The numbers often differ from the textbook description by several minutes, and they differ between brokers.

Automated systems deserve the same care. A script that does not check the spread before sending an order can enter at the worst moment of the day. A simple spread filter, refusing any trade when the spread exceeds a set multiple of its average, prevents most of the damage without any other change.

What is the widest spread ever recorded on your main pair during the rollover, and did it catch any of your orders?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: EURJPY and the opening range break: does it still work after costs?

Post by Shadow Trader »

Exotic pairs attract scalpers with big pip ranges and juicy swing potential. A 100 pip move in USDMXN is a normal day, and the headline numbers look generous.

Then reality arrives. Spreads on exotics are often many times wider than on majors, sometimes 20 to 100 pips depending on the pair and broker. A scalper who needs 5 pips to break even on a major might need 30 on an exotic. The size of moves hides how much of it goes to costs.

Other issues stack up:

1. Liquidity is thin, and fills can slip noticeably, especially around news.

2. Political events and central bank decisions can cause enormous gaps. Turkish lira moves in particular have produced sudden jumps that blew through stops.

3. Swap costs can be extreme, because interest rates in these countries are often far from the dollar's. Holding a position on the wrong side bleeds money daily.

4. Trading hours matter more. Liquidity concentrates in specific windows, and outside them spreads blow out.

5. Some brokers restrict leverage or limit exotic trading during volatile periods.

For scalping specifically, exotics rarely work well because the cost per trade is too high relative to realistic short-term targets. Some traders adapt by holding for longer, turning scalps into intraday trades, which changes the entire risk profile.

That doesn't mean exotics are always bad. A trader with a well-tested approach on a specific exotic, understanding its session behaviour and costs, can find opportunities. But the testing needs to use real spreads, including the widened spreads during bad moments.

The cleanest check is to compute the break-even move in pips for each pair, including spread and commission, and compare it with the average move over the scalp's time horizon. If break-even is a big fraction of the typical move, the maths is working against the trader before anything else.

Are exotics traded at all, and if so, what's the break-even calculation?
Post Reply