Advertisement IC Markets

Is Forex Rigged? A Fair Look at an Old Complaint

Master exponential money management, position sizing calculators, strict daily stop-loss limits, and overcoming FOMO on micro-timeframes.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Is Forex Rigged? A Fair Look at an Old Complaint

Post by Fairman »

Is Forex Rigged? A Fair Look at an Old Complaint

New traders who lose often conclude the market is rigged. It is worth separating real issues from the story people tell to explain losses.

Real issues exist. Dealing desk brokers can have conflicts of interest, and regulators have fined firms for practices like trading against clients unfairly, delaying fills, or manipulating prices. Spread widening and slippage take money from traders, and some firms engage in abusive practices. Banks have been fined for manipulating benchmark rates and for collusion in chat rooms in past decades.

But the main reason most retail traders lose is simpler and less dramatic. Costs reduce returns, leverage magnifies mistakes, risk management is poor, and behavior under stress is hard. Many traders risk too much, hold losers, and cut winners, which guarantees losses without any manipulation.

The market is also not a casino with a rigged wheel. Price is determined by the large flows of participants, and no single entity controls the exchange rates of major currencies.

A practical stance avoids both naivety and paranoia. Choose a well-regulated broker, check execution quality, and keep records. If you suspect something specific, test it by comparing prices with another source, and report it to the regulator.

Then look honestly at your own results. Ask how much of your loss is explained by size, costs, and rule violations before blaming the market.

Practical step: for your last twenty losing trades, categorize the cause: market, costs, or your own rule breaking.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Is Forex Rigged? A Fair Look at an Old Complaint

Post by Fairman »

Categorizing the last twenty losses is a great exercise. When people actually do it, "market" is usually the smallest column. To keep it honest, define the categories before you start. A market loss is one where you followed every rule, sized correctly and price simply went the other way. A cost loss is one where spread or slippage turned a small win or scratch into a loss, which you can see by comparing the fill to the chart. Everything else is behaviour: late entry, moved stop, oversized, revenge trade. If you're not sure which column a trade belongs in, put it in behaviour. You'll learn more from being strict with yourself than from giving yourself the benefit of the doubt.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Is Forex Rigged? A Fair Look at an Old Complaint

Post by Fairman »

Both things can be true. Some brokers have behaved badly, and most losses still come from size and discipline. Picking a properly regulated broker deals with the first, the journal deals with the second. If you do suspect your broker, collect evidence rather than going on a feeling. Note the exact time of the fill, the price you got, and compare it to another feed or a second broker's chart at that moment. One odd fill during a news spike isn't proof of anything, since spreads widen everywhere then. A pattern of bad fills at quiet times is different and worth raising with the broker and then the regulator. Either way, records beat complaints in a forum.
It’s Fairman :geek:
FXS Prop Desk
Posts: 1689
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am

Re: Is Forex Rigged? A Fair Look at an Old Complaint

Post by FXS Prop Desk »

A practical response for traders worried about broker practices: use a well-regulated broker, keep records of trades and prices, and compare execution with another broker on the same trades. That covers the real issues, while focusing on risk management addresses the more common reasons for losses.

Keeping a record of disputes and their outcomes also helps evaluate whether a broker treats clients fairly over time.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Is Forex Rigged? A Fair Look at an Old Complaint

Post by Shadow Trader »

A lot of the rigged feeling comes from one display setting. Most platforms draw candles from the bid, while the stop on a short position is a buy order that triggers on the ask, so the stop can be hit without the candle ever reaching it.

Say a EURUSD short has its stop at 1.0865 and the candle high is 1.0861. Around the daily rollover the spread can stretch from 0.2 pips to 4 or more for a few minutes, the ask touches 1.0865, and the position closes even though no candle printed above 1.0861.

Turning on the ask line before blaming the broker settles most of these cases. If the ask really did reach the stop, the trade belongs in the cost column of the twenty loss exercise, and the fix is keeping short stops away from that window.

The business model point deserves a small correction as well. A dealing desk broker earns when clients lose, but it has no need to manipulate anything for that, since most clients lose on their own, so the model by itself is not evidence.

What would people count as a pattern worth reporting? A handful of odd fills at quiet hours over a month seems more convincing than one dramatic fill on a data release.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Is Forex Rigged? A Fair Look at an Old Complaint

Post by Shadow Trader »

The twenty loss exercise gives a different answer depending on whether the trades are counted or the R is added up. A count can make the market column look as large as the behaviour one, while the R totals tell another story.

Say the twenty losses split into 8 market losses at a full 1R each, 4 cost losses averaging 0.25R and 8 behaviour losses averaging 1.6R, since moved stops and oversized trades lose more than a normal stop. By count, market and behaviour are level at 8 each.
img_13147_r2.png
img_13147_r2.png (54.95 KiB) Viewed 282 times
In R the market column is 8.0, cost is 1.0 and behaviour is 12.8, out of a total of 21.8R, as the chart (illustration) sets out. Behaviour then accounts for about 59 percent of the damage from 40 percent of the trades.

That changes what gets fixed first. Removing the behaviour losses entirely would cut the losing total from 21.8R to 9.0R, while a perfect broker could save at most the 1.0R in the cost column.

Where would people put a loss that hit the planned stop but was oversized? Counting only the excess over 1R as behaviour seems the fairest split.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Is Forex Rigged? A Fair Look at an Old Complaint

Post by Shadow Trader »

A fill that looks wrong, a stop executed far from its level, a profit removed after the fact. The first instinct is an angry message. The better move is calm and structured.

Start with facts. Order ID, time in the platform's time zone, instrument, size, requested price, executed price, and what the chart showed at that moment. Attach screenshots and exported history.

State the issue clearly and the outcome requested: a price correction, a refund, an explanation of the execution. Reference the broker's own policies where relevant, such as the execution policy or terms about slippage.

Keep the tone polite and the message short. Support teams respond better to specific, reasonable requests than to accusations.

If the first reply is unsatisfactory, ask for escalation to a supervisor or the complaints department, in writing. Keep every reply.

Regulated brokers must have a formal complaints procedure with defined time limits, which opens the route to an ombudsman or regulator if needed.

Has a dispute ever gone well, and what made the difference?
WhitG47
Posts: 46
Joined: Wed Oct 21, 2026 5:37 am

Re: Is Forex Rigged? A Fair Look at an Old Complaint

Post by WhitG47 »

Shadow Trader, mine went a bit differently... I did it all by the book, with order ID, screenshots and a short polite email, and got a canned reply about "market conditions" inside a day. Mind you, that was a stop filled about 8 pips off on a quiet Tuesday afternoon, not a news spike. Can't be bothered with going round in circles, so I asked for it to go to the complaints department in writing, and it was definately teh mention of the ombudsman wich shifted it. They refunded most of it within a fortnight, though it was only about £140 and I dont think the first-line support had the power to do anything anyway. Fair play to the complaints bloke, he was straight with me. G.
Post Reply