Advertisement IC Markets

Ending on process score even if P&L begs for more

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
LondonScalper
Posts: 965
Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am

Ending on process score even if P&L begs for more

Post by LondonScalper »

Ending on process score when P&L begs for more

Green days are dangerous. The chart still moves, the spread looks fine, and the account whispers for one more. I used to answer that whisper and donate the morning’s work into late-session noise. Now I answer a process score instead of the P&L line.

Before London I write three process items I will honour — examples: no revenge size, no news chase, time-stop every scalp. At the end of the planned window I score myself 0–3. If I am 3/3, I am allowed to stop even if I am up less than I “wanted.” If I am 1/3, I stop especially if I am green — luck is not a licence to keep clicking.

Desk rule: process score closes the book, not the P&L line. It feels odd the first fortnight. Then you notice the give-back trades vanish from the journal and Fridays stop being a second job.

Do you have a non-P&L exit criterion for the day, or does the green number still talk you into overtime?
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
PropScalpDesk
Posts: 521
Joined: Sat Sep 19, 2026 7:50 pm

Re: Ending on process score even if P&L begs for more

Post by PropScalpDesk »

I like the scoring, with one reservation. If the three process items are chosen fresh each morning, it's easy to drift towards items you already know you'll pass. I keep the same three for a whole month and only swap one at the monthly review. That way the 3/3 means the same thing every day.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Ending on process score even if P&L begs for more

Post by Shadow Trader »

The score as described gets counted at the end of the planned window, and that is where I hit a snag. If I break the revenge size item at 08:25, I still have ninety minutes of clicking before the score is official, and those minutes were exactly where my give-back trades lived.

So I score live. The moment an item fails, the book closes whatever the P&L says, and the end of window score only matters on days when nothing broke.

That leaves 2/3 as the awkward middle LondonScalper did not spell out. For me a 2/3 day means the window ends on time with no extension, even if a clean setup is forming right at the close.

I agree with PropScalpDesk about keeping the items fixed for a month. I would add that at least one item should be something you genuinely fail now and then, otherwise the score turns into a ritual that says 3/3 every morning.

My hard item at the moment is the time stop on every scalp, which I still miss roughly one session a week. Which of your three do you fail most often?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Ending on process score even if P&L begs for more

Post by Shadow Trader »

The post covers the green day that begs for more, but the red day with a clean 3/3 tempted me just as much. Everything was done right, the losses were ordinary, and stopping on time felt like leaving with the job unfinished.

The rule handles it fine if you let it. A 3/3 red day closes at the planned time like any other, and my worst extensions were on exactly those days, because a clean score felt like permission.

After two months of scoring I had 41 sessions. 24 were 3/3 and 17 of those finished green, 11 were 2/3 with 5 green, and the 6 days at 1/3 or worse had only 2 green.

That is a small sample, and good days make it easier to follow rules, so the cause runs both ways. It was still enough to stop me treating the score as a nicety next to the P&L.

One edge case is a trade still open when the window ends. Mine keeps its existing stop and target with no adjustment, and no new entry is allowed while it runs, even if the score is perfect.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Ending on process score even if P&L begs for more

Post by Shadow Trader »

Ten trades. Four wins, six losses. Net negative. Time to scrap the strategy?

Not necessarily, and the reason is basic statistics. With a small sample, results swing wildly around the true average. A system with a genuine 55% win rate will have a day with 40% more often than most people expect. Ten trades say very little about whether the edge exists.

What ten trades can say is whether the rules were followed. That's the question worth asking after a short run. Did each entry match the criteria? Were stops respected? Was size consistent?

Judging the strategy takes a bigger sample, often a couple of hundred trades across different conditions. Judging the process can happen every single day.

A neat habit here is separating two scores at the end of each day. Score one: did the plan get followed, yes or no. Score two: P&L. Over a few months, the first score tells whether the process is solid, while the second score is mostly noise at small sample sizes. Weeks of "process yes, P&L negative" are often just variance. Weeks of "process no, P&L positive" are a warning wearing a green coat.

So how many trades does it take before a verdict on a strategy feels fair, and what's the rule for not abandoning something too soon?
Post Reply