Advertisement IC Markets

Expert advisor whitelist blacklist experiences on prop

Navigate the rules, daily drawdown limits, and consistency guidelines of prop trading firms. Discuss how to pass funded account challenges using scalping strategies.
Post Reply
PropScalpDesk
Posts: 521
Joined: Sat Sep 19, 2026 7:50 pm

Expert advisor whitelist blacklist experiences on prop

Post by PropScalpDesk »

I only run defensive scripts: flatten on daily loss, block orders in a blackout window. No entry EAs on prop accounts I care about.

Experience in plain terms: anything that places or manages entries without me clicking gets treated as higher scrutiny. I assume whitelist/blacklist language varies by firm and changes. So my practice is minimal automation, documented in my own notes, and tested on a throwaway challenge first if I must.

If a firm forbids EAs entirely, the flatten habit moves to a physical checklist and a hard personal stop. I would rather lose a little efficiency than argue about a script after a breach. Prop scalping already asks for discretion. Adding grey-area automation is optional risk I usually decline.

Whatever you run, keep a plain-language note of what it can do. If you cannot explain it in two sentences, it does not belong on an evaluated account. I would rather miss a flatten automation than surprise a risk desk with an undocumented helper. Document the kill switch path in the same note. If the script misbehaves, I need one obvious way to disable it without closing the whole terminal.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Expert advisor whitelist blacklist experiences on prop

Post by Shadow Trader »

The two sentence rule is a good test. I'd add one more line to the note: what the script does if the connection drops. My flatten on daily loss script works fine while the terminal is connected, but during a disconnection it can't do anything, and the firm's limit keeps counting.

So my plain language note now has a third sentence: if the connection is lost, the script does nothing, so the physical checklist applies.

On the order blocking script, I've had a question from a risk desk once. Not about the blocking itself, but about why there were rejected orders in the log. The script cancelled them locally, but the firm's side saw the attempts.

I now block at the button level, before the order is sent, so nothing reaches the server.

I'd be interested in whether anyone has asked a firm directly for written confirmation that a defensive script is allowed. I tried once and got a reply that was so general it didn't really help.

What do you use for the kill switch? I have a hotkey that removes the script from the chart, but I'm not sure that's obvious enough.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Expert advisor whitelist blacklist experiences on prop

Post by Shadow Trader »

Firms that ban EAs entirely usually still allow the platform's own features, like a stop loss or a native trailing stop. I wondered for a while whether a trailing stop counts as automation under some terms.

A different firm from the one I mentioned gave me a clearer written answer. Platform features are fine, but a third party tool changing order parameters after placement is not, so the native trailing stop is allowed while a breakeven script sits in a grey area.

That changed how I manage trades on those accounts. I move to breakeven by hand there, or set the native trailing stop at entry, and the breakeven script stays on my own account.

On testing with a throwaway challenge, I'd add a test during a news release. My flatten script once took about three seconds to close everything in a fast move, far longer than in quiet hours.

Has anyone been flagged for running a trade copier between their own accounts at the same firm? It seems to be the grey area I hear about most.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Expert advisor whitelist blacklist experiences on prop

Post by Shadow Trader »

Trading software is an appealing delivery vehicle for malware, because users expect to install programs, grant permissions and enter credentials. Fake platform installers often appear in search advertisements or in links from messages, imitating the real download page. A cracked version of a paid indicator or automated robot may work as advertised while also installing a keylogger or a remote-access tool.

Expert advisors are code that runs with considerable freedom inside the platform. A file obtained from an unknown source can request permission to contact external web addresses, which allows data to be sent away. Compiled files whose source cannot be inspected make the risk harder to judge. Tools that ask for a master password, when a read-only investor password would suffice, should be questioned.

Safer habits include downloading platforms only from the broker's verified site or the developer's official page, checking that the installer carries a valid digital publisher signature, and scanning files before opening them. Trading from a separate device or user profile limits the damage if something goes wrong. Software should be kept updated, and any request for administrator rights, screen sharing or a remote-support session in order to fix a problem is a warning sign.

Anything purchased should come from a seller with a traceable history and a clear refund policy.
Post Reply