Advertisement IC Markets

EURJPY and the news reaction scalp: does it still work after costs?

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
LondonScalper
Posts: 965
Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am

EURJPY and the news reaction scalp: does it still work after costs?

Post by LondonScalper »

EURJPY news-reaction scalp — still worth it after costs?

EURJPY into data can move enough to tempt a news-reaction scalp. After costs and slippage tails, mine often looked busy rather than positive expectancy — lots of screenshots, weak R after the bill.

How I stress-test the variant before I keep it in the menu:
  • Only after stand-aside timer and spread filter — no first-tick heroics.
  • Fixed time-stop; no “thesis expansion” mid-trade when it goes wrong.
  • Compare expectancy to plain London continuation on the same pair without the news tax.
If the news variant underperforms the boring variant after costs, I bench the drama. Activity is not edge.

Has EURJPY news-reaction survived your cost log, or did you retire it for cleaner session trades?

When the news variant loses the comparison for a full quarter, it stays benched even if a single dramatic winner tempts a comeback. One firework does not restart a retired playbook.

Dramatic winners are vivid; cost columns are quiet. Believe the quiet page.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: EURJPY and the news reaction scalp: does it still work after costs?

Post by Shadow Trader »

Mine didn't survive, and the gross numbers were what fooled me for a while. The news variant actually made more per trade before costs than plain London continuation on the same pair, it just paid far more to do it.

I sketched the averages from one quarter of my log in the attached illustration, 41 news trades against 96 continuation trades. News grossed +2.4 pips a trade and continuation +1.5, but after spread, slippage and commission the news side ended at -0.2 and continuation at +0.3.
img_12571_r1.png
img_12571_r1.png (59.38 KiB) Viewed 267 times
Commission was the same 0.5 pips on both, so the whole gap was spread and slippage. Even with a stand-aside timer my average entry spread on news trades was 1.3 pips against 0.6 normally, and slippage was 0.8 against 0.1.

One edge case I'd add to your stress test is which news you count. On my sheet the worst EURJPY spreads weren't around euro data at all, they were US releases at 13:30 London, where the cross gets repriced through USDJPY and both legs widen at once.

Did you test a longer stand-aside timer before retiring it? I tried going from 60 to 180 seconds and the spread improved, but most of the gross edge was gone by then too.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: EURJPY and the news reaction scalp: does it still work after costs?

Post by Shadow Trader »

LondonScalper, after retiring the broad news variant I tested keeping only ECB and BOJ windows on EURJPY. That cut the sample to 11 trades in a quarter, and after costs it landed at about plus 0.1R, which is still too thin for me to restart the playbook.

The cleaner comparison was against USDJPY on the same US releases. USDJPY paid similar gross movement with roughly half the spread tax on my book, because a single leg was widening instead of both.

So if I ever revive a news reaction scalp on a yen cross, it will be USDJPY first, with EURJPY staying on plain London continuation only. The dual leg problem was the quiet killer in the cost column.

I still log the skipped EURJPY news windows so the itch has a page to sit on. Did your cost sheet ever favour one release type enough to keep a narrow variant, or was the whole news bucket retired together?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: EURJPY and the news reaction scalp: does it still work after costs?

Post by Shadow Trader »

Fibonacci retracements are among the most popular tools in technical analysis. Whether they have predictive power is debated, and the debate is more interesting than either side admits.

Supporters note that price often reacts near the 38.2, 50, and 61.8 percent levels. Critics point out that there are so many levels, and so many swings to choose from, that some line will always sit near a reversal.

There is a more nuanced view. The levels work, to the extent they work, because many traders watch them. Orders cluster around them, which creates a reaction, and that reaction reinforces belief. That makes them partly self-fulfilling.

Whether that effect is strong enough to profit from after costs is an empirical question. A fair test would define the swing selection rule in advance, mark every retracement over a few months, and record how often price bounced from each level.

Without a fixed rule for choosing swings, any result is contaminated by hindsight, since the swing that fits best gets picked after the fact.

One method to reduce hindsight is to draw the retracement tool in real time during the session and save screenshots before the outcome is known. A set of fifty of these, reviewed later, gives an honest hit rate for the technique as actually used, including the cases where the wrong swing was picked.

Has anyone tested Fibonacci retracements with a strict, pre-defined swing rule, and what did the numbers say?
Post Reply