Page 1 of 1

Mistakes I made with public trading journals

Posted: Fri Sep 18, 2026 3:27 pm
by LondonScalper
Public journals — what I got wrong

Years ago I posted a public trading journal “for accountability.” It did the opposite. I started writing for an audience: polishing language, under-reporting dumb clicks, and stretching reviews so they looked professional. The journal became marketing, not feedback.

Three mistakes that cost me clarity:
  • Delayed honesty — waiting until evening to write when the emotion had already faded
  • Metric theatre — win rate screenshots without cost and R distribution
  • Comment chasing — editing posts after replies instead of logging the next session cleanly
What works for me now is a private raw log plus a sanitised monthly summary if I share anything. Accountability buddy in DM beats a public thread when the goal is behaviour, not applause. The audience never saw the trades I was ashamed of — and those were the ones that needed daylight.

If you keep a public journal: what rules stop you gaming it? And if you abandoned public logging, what replaced it without losing the discipline?

Re: Mistakes I made with public trading journals

Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2026 9:59 am
by Shadow Trader
Comment chasing is the one I recognise most. I kept a public thread for about six months and noticed I'd started taking trades that would make a good post. Clean London breakouts got screenshots, while the two scratches before them got one line.

What stopped me gaming it was a fixed template with no free text in the first part. Time, pair, planned R, result in R, rule followed yes or no. Only after that could I write anything, and the numbers were already there.

I'd disagree slightly on public being worse than DMs. For me the problem wasn't the audience, it was being able to edit. A log I couldn't edit after posting, even if nobody read it, kept me more honest than a buddy who only saw what I chose to send.

When you share the monthly summary, does it include the rule break count? That's the number I'd want to see from anyone posting results.

Re: Mistakes I made with public trading journals

Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2026 10:10 am
by PTScalper
LondonScalper wrote: Fri Sep 18, 2026 3:27 pm Public journals — what I got wrong

Years ago I posted a public trading journal “for accountability.” It did the opposite. I started writing for an audience: polishing language, under-reporting dumb clicks, and stretching reviews so they looked professional. The journal became marketing, not feedback.

Three mistakes that cost me clarity:
  • Delayed honesty — waiting until evening to write when the emotion had already faded
  • Metric theatre — win rate screenshots without cost and R distribution
  • Comment chasing — editing posts after replies instead of logging the next session cleanly
What works for me now is a private raw log plus a sanitised monthly summary if I share anything. Accountability buddy in DM beats a public thread when the goal is behaviour, not applause. The audience never saw the trades I was ashamed of — and those were the ones that needed daylight.

If you keep a public journal: what rules stop you gaming it? And if you abandoned public logging, what replaced it without losing the discipline?
Hi LondonScalper,

i got it, i know, that it is not the same to share your trades with audience of other people and time to time it will give you bigger pressure on yourself.
From my point of view you have to find your own way how to make it ;-)

Re: Mistakes I made with public trading journals

Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2026 10:17 am
by PTScalper
Shadow Trader wrote: Mon Oct 12, 2026 9:59 am Comment chasing is the one I recognise most. I kept a public thread for about six months and noticed I'd started taking trades that would make a good post. Clean London breakouts got screenshots, while the two scratches before them got one line.

What stopped me gaming it was a fixed template with no free text in the first part. Time, pair, planned R, result in R, rule followed yes or no. Only after that could I write anything, and the numbers were already there.

I'd disagree slightly on public being worse than DMs. For me the problem wasn't the audience, it was being able to edit. A log I couldn't edit after posting, even if nobody read it, kept me more honest than a buddy who only saw what I chose to send.

When you share the monthly summary, does it include the rule break count? That's the number I'd want to see from anyone posting results.
Hi,

what works for me is simple, most of the time i just share some of my trading account after good day or bad day, simply share reality.
I tried that in real time, but it is much more harder, because i started to do different type of trades so i stopped with that.

Re: Mistakes I made with public trading journals

Posted: Thu Oct 15, 2026 4:44 pm
by Shadow Trader
PTScalper's point about real time sharing changing the trades is exactly why I killed the live thread. The moment I knew someone might reply within the hour, I started picking the photogenic setup over the one my card actually called.

The fixed template stayed after I went private. First block is only fields I cannot soft pedal: clock, symbol, planned R, realised R, and a yes or no on rules. Free text comes after, and the rule break count sits in the monthly summary as its own line.

I'd still rather a log I cannot edit than a buddy who only sees what I send. Edit access was the real leak for me, more than the size of the audience.

Delayed honesty from LondonScalper's list is the other one I watch. If the template is not filled within fifteen minutes of the flat, the row gets a late flag, and three late flags in a week ends sharing for that month.

LondonScalper, in the monthly summary, do you show rule breaks as a count, or only as a note when something big happened? Count is the version that keeps me honest.

Re: Mistakes I made with public trading journals

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 5:49 pm
by FXS Prop Desk
PTScalper, sharing reality after good and bad days is honest, and the experience with real-time sharing changing your trades is an important warning. Knowing others are watching can push someone towards trades that look good rather than trades that fit the plan. Sharing after the fact keeps the transparency without that influence on decisions.