Page 1 of 2
Medium-impact news as a strategy filter: trade after, never through
Posted: Thu Sep 17, 2026 3:35 am
by LondonScalper
Everyone respects red-folder events. Orange and medium prints quietly ruin scalps.
My filter:
medium-impact for my pairs means trade after, never through. I may keep a runner only if it is already risk-free; I do not open fresh M1 ideas into that minute. After the print, I wait for structure — same logic as bigger events, just a shorter timer and often less drama.
This sits alongside tier-1 flat rules. The point is consistency: if the calendar can spike spreads or invite a two-tick trap, the strategy is stand-aside, not "tiny size for fun". Tiny size through medium news taught me expensive lessons that were not statistically interesting — just avoidable.
I keep a personal list of medium events that still move my pairs. The generic calendar colour is a start, not the finish.
- Do you treat medium-impact as flat, micro-size, or ignore?
- Which medium events still catch you out on your pairs?
Strategy filter, not fear.
Re: Medium-impact news as a strategy filter: trade after, never through
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2026 9:29 am
by Shadow Trader
I treat medium-impact as flat for new entries too, but I keep the list by pair rather than by calendar colour. A German state CPI is marked low on most calendars and still moves EURUSD more than half the orange events I see.
The one that still catches me out is US weekly jobless claims on a quiet Thursday. Most weeks nothing happens. Then every couple of months it prints way off forecast and EURUSD moves 15 pips in the first minute with the spread blown out.
My timer for medium events is two minutes before and three after. For tier-one it's ten and fifteen. If you sit out too long for every orange print, you lose half the London session on a busy calendar day.
On the runner, I'd be a bit careful with risk-free. A stop at entry in a spike can fill a couple of pips worse, so it isn't fully free.
How do you handle a runner when the spread widens enough to touch the stop without price really getting there? That's the case my runner rule still doesn't cover well.
Re: Medium-impact news as a strategy filter: trade after, never through
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2026 10:49 am
by Fairman
LondonScalper wrote: I keep a personal list of medium events that still move my pairs.
A few that tend to be rated orange or lower and still move things. US weekly jobless claims on Thursdays at 13:30 London, which matter more whenever the labour market is the story. JOLTS at 15:00 for the same reason. German Ifo and the ZEW survey for the euro, both in the London morning. For sterling, the BoE's Decision Maker Panel and speeches by MPC members. And speeches in general, ECB or Fed, which often aren't red on the calendar but can move a pair more than the data around them. A calendar's rating is a fixed guess about typical impact, so it ignores what the market is focused on right now. When inflation is the theme, small price releases matter; when growth is, the surveys do. That's why a personal list beats the colours, as long as it gets revisited when the story changes.
Re: Medium-impact news as a strategy filter: trade after, never through
Posted: Thu Oct 15, 2026 4:08 pm
by Shadow Trader
I've since worked out a partial answer to my own runner question. On a long, the stop is triggered by the bid, so when the spread blows out on a medium print the bid can drop through the stop while the mid price barely moves.
The attached chart is an illustration of that on EURUSD around 13:30 jobless claims. The mid dips under 2 pips, but the spread widens from 0.2 to about 2.6 pips for a few seconds, and the bid tags a stop that sat 3 pips under the price.

- img_12493_r2.png (111.48 KiB) Viewed 195 times
My rule now is that a runner held into a medium event needs its stop at least the typical spike spread beyond structure. For claims on EURUSD that is about 2.5 pips extra, and if the trade cannot afford that, I bank it before the print instead.
Fairman's point about claims mattering more when labour is the story fits here too. On those weeks I just close the runner, because the spread spike is bigger and the move afterwards is less predictable.
LondonScalper, do you keep runner stops on the server through medium prints, or pull them and manage by hand? Pulling them feels wrong to me, but I know people who do it.
Re: Medium-impact news as a strategy filter: trade after, never through
Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2026 7:15 am
by Shadow Trader
A strategy that ignores news will, sooner or later, trade straight through a major release with normal size and normal stops. The result is rarely pretty.
News filters pause trading around scheduled events. The basic version reads an economic calendar, marks events above a chosen impact level, and blocks new entries for some minutes before and after. Positions already open may be closed or have stops tightened.
The hard parts are in the details. Calendar sources differ, impact ratings are subjective, and times shift with daylight saving. Some calendars update forecasts and revisions, others don't. Unscheduled events, like surprise speeches, escape the filter entirely.
A layered approach works better: a calendar filter for scheduled events plus a volatility or spread filter that reacts to sudden changes whatever their cause. The second layer catches what the first one misses.
Backtesting a news filter needs historical calendar data, which is harder to obtain than price data.
What kind of news filter is running, and what slipped through it?
Re: Medium-impact news as a strategy filter: trade after, never through
Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2026 4:12 pm
by gwhitlock64
The daylight saving gap caught me out properly: the US and UK clocks change on different weekends, so for a week or so in March and again around late Oct/early Nov, the 13:30 claims print lands at 12:30 London time. My calendar filter was still on the old hour, so it sat there doing nothing while the spread blew out, and ive since added a spread check on top. Wierd how a bit of clock faff costs more than any bad call on direction... gutted tbh.
Re: Medium-impact news as a strategy filter: trade after, never through
Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2026 11:50 pm
by PTScalper
gwhitlock64 wrote: Tue Oct 27, 2026 4:12 pm
The daylight saving gap caught me out properly: the US and UK clocks change on different weekends, so for a week or so in March and again around late Oct/early Nov, the 13:30 claims print lands at 12:30 London time. My calendar filter was still on the old hour, so it sat there doing nothing while the spread blew out, and ive since added a spread check on top. Wierd how a bit of clock faff costs more than any bad call on direction... gutted tbh.
yeah, you are right.
Can you share with us some of your trades?
Re: Medium-impact news as a strategy filter: trade after, never through
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 12:44 pm
by gwhitlock64
PTScalper wrote:yeah, you are right. Can you share with us some of your trades?
Dont really have any pretty screenshots, mate, mine are mostly a scruffy spreadsheet. The one that stung was a small EURUSD long in late March, stop 3 pips under entry, and the spread blew out at 12:30 and tagged me for about 3.5 pips... price was back above my entry within the minute. Since then ive had a spread check on top, which has kept me flat on a few of those Thursdays, and tbh i havent missed the trades

Re: Medium-impact news as a strategy filter: trade after, never through
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 3:42 pm
by PTScalper
gwhitlock64 wrote: Wed Oct 28, 2026 12:44 pm
PTScalper wrote:yeah, you are right. Can you share with us some of your trades?
Dont really have any pretty screenshots, mate, mine are mostly a scruffy spreadsheet. The one that stung was a small EURUSD long in late March, stop 3 pips under entry, and the spread blew out at 12:30 and tagged me for about 3.5 pips... price was back above my entry within the minute. Since then ive had a spread check on top, which has kept me flat on a few of those Thursdays, and tbh i havent missed the trades
It does not have to be pretty screenshot, simply whatever you have
3.5pips is nothing, most of the time i have like 30-80 pips stop loss on eurusd.
Re: Medium-impact news as a strategy filter: trade after, never through
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 7:33 am
by gwhitlock64
PTScalper wrote:It does not have to be pretty screenshot, simply whatever you have 3.5pips is nothing, most of the time i have like 30-80 pips stop loss on eurusd.
Fair play, with a 30-80 pip stop a 3.5 pip spike is just noise, you'd never even see it. Mine only bites because im scalping with 3 pip stops, so the spread alone is bigger than the whole cushion... and going that wide would mean cutting size alot to keep the same risk, which is a different game really. Il dig out the spreadsheet rows if you want them, but its mostly columns of numbers, dont expect owt exciting.