Page 1 of 1

Indicators I removed after they cost me money

Posted: Mon Sep 14, 2026 11:42 pm
by LondonScalper
Indicators I removed after they cost me money.

Every indicator that stayed on my M1 chart had a lobbyist in my head. RSI divergence, overbought labels, extra MAs -- they delayed entries I had already planned or justified entries I should have skipped. After costs, they were noise with opinions.

Removal test
Hide one for two weeks. If expectancy and process tags do not worsen, it stays gone. I kept almost nothing beyond session boxes, levels, and a single volatility ruler used off to the side for sizing -- not on the entry decision.

Clutter is a risk control problem disguised as analysis.

What did you remove last -- and what refused to die?

I keep a graveyard list of removed indicators with the date and why. It stops me reinstalling the same MA crossover six months later with a new name. The graveyard is one of my more useful documents.

Re: Indicators I removed after they cost me money

Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2026 8:22 pm
by Shadow Trader
The graveyard list is a good idea, and I'd add one column to it: what the indicator was supposed to do for me. Mine had RSI divergence listed as entry timing, and once I wrote that down it was obvious I already had a timing rule from the levels themselves.

My removal test was similar, with a small difference. Instead of hiding an indicator for two weeks, I kept it on a second chart that I only looked at after the trade was closed. That let me record whether it would have changed the decision, without it actually changing it.

Over a month, the MA crossover would have kept me out of 11 trades. Eight of those were winners. That settled it.

The one that refused to die for me was the volume indicator. Tick volume isn't real volume, I know, but I kept finding it useful around the open to see whether a breakout had activity behind it.

Do you keep the volatility ruler on the M1 or on a higher timeframe? I've found ATR on M1 too jumpy to size from.

Re: Indicators I removed after they cost me money

Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2026 11:07 pm
by Shadow Trader
There's a version of the clutter problem that isn't indicators at all: drawn lines. My charts used to collect support and resistance from weeks ago, and every old line became a reason to doubt a trade, exactly like your lobbyists.

My rule now is that every horizontal line carries a date. Anything older than five trading days gets deleted on Monday morning unless it's a weekly high or low.

Session boxes got the same treatment, and I only show today's and yesterday's. With a full week on screen I kept finding reasons price might react at an old Asian high nobody else was watching.

I'd be interested in how you define the process tags for the removal test. I use three, on plan, early and late, and if removing an indicator raises the late entries, it was doing something useful.

Has anyone added one back after the two week test and found it genuinely helped? I'd like to hear about one that survived.

Re: Indicators I removed after they cost me money

Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2026 8:50 am
by Fairman
LondonScalper wrote: Hide one for two weeks. If expectancy and process tags do not worsen, it stays gone.
Two weeks is a short window for this kind of test, so I'm curious how many trades it usually gives you. The test is sound in spirit, but the burden of proof sits on one side. If it's around 30 trades, expectancy can easily move by a few tenths of R from noise alone, so did not worsen is likely to pass almost every time, and nearly any indicator would get removed. That might be fine if the goal is a cleaner chart anyway. But if you wanted the test to be able to keep something useful, you'd need either a longer window or a less noisy measure, like counting how often the indicator changed a decision before the click. Did any indicator ever survive the two-week hide?

Re: Indicators I removed after they cost me money

Posted: Sat Oct 31, 2026 12:09 am
by Shadow Trader
Emerging market pairs look tempting for scalpers because they move. USDMXN can cover 50 or 100 pips in an hour without much news, and USDZAR is famous for its big swings. The danger is hiding in plain sight, in the fine print of how those pairs are priced.

Spreads on exotics are quoted in points, and the numbers are bigger. A "tight" spread of 30 points on USDZAR is still a different animal from 0.2 pips on EURUSD. Convert it into money per lot and the cost can be several times higher for the same notional size.

Liquidity is also concentrated in specific time windows. Mexico trades mostly during the New York session, South Africa during London, and outside those hours the pair becomes thin quickly. A quote can jump a few hundred points between ticks.

Then there are the swaps. High-yield currencies pay or charge significant amounts, and brokers set rates that can include a generous markup. A trade closed inside a minute isn't affected unless it straddles rollover, but the rollover spread on these pairs is nasty, often ten times the normal figure.

Finally, headline risk. Political events in either country can move the pair 2 or 3 percent in a session, and the broker may widen spreads to a point where closing a position is expensive.

None of that makes the pairs untradable. It just means the cost-per-trade calculation needs to be done separately, using real fills, before assuming that bigger moves mean bigger profits.

A quick illustration of the cost side. Suppose USDZAR quotes with a 25 point spread, and the pair's pip is 10 points. That's 2.5 pips. For a standard lot, with a pip value of roughly a dollar or so per point depending on the rate, the cost could be 20 to 25 dollars per round trip. EURUSD at 0.3 pips costs about 3 dollars on the same size.

The move per minute is bigger on the rand, but the ratio of move to spread is what counts, and it isn't automatically better.

Has anyone found a time window where USDMXN or USDZAR actually trades cleanly enough for tight targets?