Advertisement IC Markets

Pre-news positioning debates: edge or gamble?

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
LondonScalper
Posts: 965
Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2026 7:54 am

Pre-news positioning debates: edge or gamble?

Post by LondonScalper »

Pre-news positioning: edge or gamble? My ledger says gamble for scalpers.

Sitting into a known release with a directional scalp is a different game from post-news structure. Spreads explode, slippage dominates, and your stop is a suggestion. I have done it; the winners felt brilliant and the losers were outsized. Net, not worth it for my hold times.

Where I stand
No intentional pre-positioning for tier-1. If I am caught in a trade approaching a blackout, I flatten early rather than "hope." People trading event volatility with a real plan and size model are not what I am doing on M1.

Curious whether anyone here has a rules-based pre-news scalp that survives costs -- or whether most "I caught NFP" stories omit the silent graveyard.

If your edge truly is event volatility, say so and size like a different strategy -- wider stops, different hold, different venue assumptions. Mixing event gambling into a scalping journal poisons both. Separation is clarity; clarity is risk control.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: Pre-news positioning debates: edge or gamble?

Post by Fairman »

LondonScalper wrote: or whether most "I caught NFP" stories omit the silent graveyard.
Survivorship is exactly the issue. The structural problem for a scalper is that the payoff gets decided by the gap at the release, not by your stop. Say you're long EURUSD with a 5 pip stop into CPI and the print goes against you. You can get filled 15 or 20 pips away, so a 1R loss becomes 3 or 4R, while the winners are capped by wherever you were planning to take profit anyway. Unless the directional hit rate is well above half, that asymmetry runs the wrong way. The versions that make more sense on paper are the ones built around options or straddles, where the max loss is known before the number comes out.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Pre-news positioning debates: edge or gamble?

Post by Shadow Trader »

The "caught in a trade approaching a blackout" case is where I see most of the damage, more than deliberate pre-positioning. People plan to flatten, then wait one more minute for the target, and the spread gets there first.

On a lot of feeds EURUSD spreads start widening a minute or two before a tier-1 release, not at the release itself. Flatten at T minus 1 and you're often paying a wider spread than you planned.

I use T minus 5, and I close at market rather than hoping a limit fills. Missing the last few pips of a target costs less than one exit into a blown-out spread.

Where I'd push you is tier-2. Weekly jobless claims or a mid-tier print can still move gold hard, and nobody treats those as pre-positioning. My blackout list for XAUUSD is longer than for EURUSD for that reason.

There's also a grey area: the drift in the 30 to 60 minutes before something like NFP. Scalping that drift and being flat by T minus 5 isn't sitting into the number, but some people journal it as if it were.

So where do you draw it? Do trades taken in that pre-release drift count under your no pre-positioning rule, or only trades still open at the number?
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Pre-news positioning debates: edge or gamble?

Post by Shadow Trader »

Fairman's mention of straddles is worth splitting in two. An options straddle has a known max loss, but the retail version is a buy stop above and a sell stop below, set a minute before the number.

That version has no known max loss at all. Stop orders fill at the first available price, and in the first seconds after a release that can be several pips past the trigger, on both the entry and the exit.

Sketch below of a typical bad one: buy stop 1.1655, sell stop 1.1645, 7 pip stops on each, and a print that fills both legs for 26 pips lost instead of the planned 14. The spike fills the long three pips late, the reversal stops it out and fills the short, and the bounce takes the short out too.
img_12410_r2.png
img_12410_r2.png (111.74 KiB) Viewed 130 times
The winners people screenshot are the ones where the first move kept going far enough to cover the slippage. Most straddle stories I've read show the NFP that worked and skip the CPI that filled both legs.

For a rules-based version I'd want every event logged, with fills against trigger prices and both sides counted. I'd also be curious whether anyone has tested placing it 30 seconds after the release instead, once the first gap is done.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Pre-news positioning debates: edge or gamble?

Post by Shadow Trader »

In the hour before a major release, price often creeps in one direction on thin volume, then the data lands and everything reverses. Traders call it pre-positioning, and it traps anyone who reads the drift as a trend.

The mechanics are mundane. Some participants place bets ahead of time, others pull liquidity so quotes get thin, and a handful of orders can push price further than usual. When the number prints, the thin drift unwinds in seconds.

A scalper who joins the creep at 1:15pm for a 2:30pm release is paying a wider spread to ride a move with no real fuel behind it. If the data surprises the other way, the stop gets a hard test.

A discipline many follow: no new trades in the last thirty minutes before a high-impact event unless the setup is part of a defined news strategy. Existing positions get closed or trimmed, since stop slippage around releases can be brutal.

Is a pre-news cutoff in place, and how many minutes before the release does it start?
Post Reply