Two pricing models exist: spread-only (wider spread, no commission) and commission-based (tight spread plus fixed commission). For high-frequency scalpers, the choice matters more than for most traders.
Spread-only:
- Simpler to calculate.
- Cost varies with spread, which widens at volatile times.
- No separate commission line in statements.
Commission-based:
- Fixed commission per lot, plus variable but tight spread.
- More predictable total cost in calm markets.
- Usually cheaper overall for frequent traders.
Break-even comparison:
If commission is $7 per lot round turn (0.7 pips on EURUSD) and raw spread averages 0.2, total is 0.9 pips. If the spread-only account averages 1.0 pip, the commission account is cheaper by 0.1 pip per trade.
But for traders using small sizes (e.g. 0.01 lots), some brokers have minimum commissions that make the commission model expensive.
Also check: is commission charged on opening, closing, or both? Some charge per side.
Which model do you use? Have you calculated the break-even for your volume?
Commission vs spread pricing for high-frequency entries
-
FXS London Scalper
- Posts: 1046
- Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm
Commission vs spread pricing for high-frequency entries
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2194
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Commission vs spread pricing for high-frequency entries
The break-even maths is the right way to look at this, and it gets even clearer if you work it out per round trip at your actual trade size and the hours you trade. Raw spreads on majors are often close to zero in London and New York, but they widen at rollover and around news, so an average taken over the whole day can flatter or punish one model depending on when you're active. Pull your own trade history and calculate the cost per trade from that.
Watch for how commission is quoted. Some brokers state it per side per lot, some per round turn, and some per million notional, which shifts with the exchange rate on non-USD accounts. Converting everything to pips per round trip on the pair you trade most is the only fair comparison.
For very frequent small entries, also check the minimum commission and whether swaps or account fees differ between the two account types. Those details can wipe out the apparent saving once you add up a month of volume.
Watch for how commission is quoted. Some brokers state it per side per lot, some per round turn, and some per million notional, which shifts with the exchange rate on non-USD accounts. Converting everything to pips per round trip on the pair you trade most is the only fair comparison.
For very frequent small entries, also check the minimum commission and whether swaps or account fees differ between the two account types. Those details can wipe out the apparent saving once you add up a month of volume.