Some prop firms add a markup to spreads or charge higher commission than a typical retail raw account. For scalpers, even a small markup affects expectancy significantly.
Example:
- Your strategy on a raw account: 0.2 pip spread + 0.7 pip commission = 0.9 pips cost per trade.
- Prop firm: 0.4 pip spread + 0.7 pip commission = 1.1 pips.
With a 4-pip target and 4-pip stop:
- Raw: break-even win rate = (4 + 0.9) / 8 = 61.25%.
- Prop: (4 + 1.1) / 8 = 63.75%.
If your strategy wins 62%, it's profitable on raw and losing on prop.
What to do:
- Measure the actual spread on the prop account during your trading hours.
- Recalculate break-even win rate with prop costs.
- Consider wider targets to make costs a smaller share.
Have you compared your costs on prop vs personal accounts?
Prop firm spread markups: recalculating expectancy
-
FXS London Scalper
- Posts: 1046
- Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm
Prop firm spread markups: recalculating expectancy
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5744
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
Re: Prop firm spread markups: recalculating expectancy
The break-even win rate calculation is the clearest way to show why small cost differences matter so much for scalpers. A difference of 0.2 pips does not sound like much, but on a target of four pips it is a large proportion of the edge.
One thing I would add is that the spread used in the calculation should be the spread at the actual time of entry, not the average over the day. If a firm's spreads are close to raw during the main London hours but much wider in the first few minutes of the session or around releases, a scalper who trades those moments faces a different cost than the average suggests.
Slippage should also go into the calculation. On a raw retail account, slippage might be small but not zero. If the prop account has a different execution model, slippage can add more to the cost than the markup itself. Measuring the difference between requested and filled prices over a few weeks gives a real number to work with.
Widening targets is one way to absorb the extra cost, but it changes the win rate of the strategy too, because a wider target is reached less often. The new break-even rate has to be compared with the new win rate, not the old one. That needs testing rather than assuming.
Another option is to reduce the number of trades and keep only the setups with the largest average favourable move. Those are the trades where a cost increase eats the smallest share of the result.
It would be useful if members posted measured spreads at specific times for the firms they use, so the comparison is based on real numbers rather than advertised averages.
One thing I would add is that the spread used in the calculation should be the spread at the actual time of entry, not the average over the day. If a firm's spreads are close to raw during the main London hours but much wider in the first few minutes of the session or around releases, a scalper who trades those moments faces a different cost than the average suggests.
Slippage should also go into the calculation. On a raw retail account, slippage might be small but not zero. If the prop account has a different execution model, slippage can add more to the cost than the markup itself. Measuring the difference between requested and filled prices over a few weeks gives a real number to work with.
Widening targets is one way to absorb the extra cost, but it changes the win rate of the strategy too, because a wider target is reached less often. The new break-even rate has to be compared with the new win rate, not the old one. That needs testing rather than assuming.
Another option is to reduce the number of trades and keep only the setups with the largest average favourable move. Those are the trades where a cost increase eats the smallest share of the result.
It would be useful if members posted measured spreads at specific times for the firms they use, so the comparison is based on real numbers rather than advertised averages.