Advertisement IC Markets

Testing two brokers with the same strategy and size

Compare ECN/Raw spread brokers, analyze execution speeds, report slippage, and evaluate commission structures for high-frequency traders.
Post Reply
FXS London Scalper
Posts: 1024
Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm

Testing two brokers with the same strategy and size

Post by FXS London Scalper »

Comparing brokers fairly means running the same trades on both accounts at the same moment. Anything else mixes broker differences with market differences.

Setup:
  • Both terminals on one VPS.
  • A simple copier script places the same order on the second account within milliseconds.
  • Same lot size, same stops and targets.
  • A few weeks of normal trading, including some data days.
What to compare per trade: fill price difference, slippage against requested price, spread at entry, commission, and final result in money.

How to read results: small differences per trade add up. A worked example: a 0.1 pip average difference on 300 lots a month is $300. But look at the distribution too. A broker that's slightly better on average and much worse on the 5% of trades during news may still be the worse choice.

Watch for copier delay biasing results. Alternate which account receives the order first each week.

Has anyone run a test like this for more than a month?
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5694
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Testing two brokers with the same strategy and size

Post by Shadow Trader »

This is a good method, and alternating which account receives the order first is a smart way to deal with copier delay. A few additions that might make the comparison more reliable:

Record the time of day for each trade, so the results can be split by session. A broker might be close to the other during London but noticeably worse during the Asian session or around the daily rollover. Averages over the whole day can hide that.

Separate news trades from normal trades in the analysis. As you say, a broker can look slightly better on average but much worse during news. Looking at the two groups separately makes the trade-off clear, and lets each trader decide based on how often they trade around releases.

Track rejections and requotes as well as slippage. A trade that was rejected, or filled only after a delay, may not show up as slippage but still costs money in missed opportunities.

Make sure the account types are truly comparable. A raw spread account with commission at one broker should be compared with a similar account at the other, not with a standard account where costs are built into the spread.

Consider the sample size. A few weeks of normal trading may be enough to see big differences, but small differences in average slippage can be noise unless there are a few hundred trades behind them. It helps to look at the spread of results, not just the average.

Keep an eye on swaps if any trades are held overnight. For scalpers this is usually minor, but it can matter for strategies that occasionally hold positions longer.

One more thought: the same comparison repeated a few months later can be useful, because execution quality can change as brokers change liquidity providers or as market conditions shift.

How large were the differences you have seen between brokers that looked similar on paper? It would be interesting to know whether the gap tends to be in the averages or mostly in the tails.
Post Reply