Over-optimising the entry by one tick
A setup is valid. The price is right there. But a trader waits for a slightly better entry, one tick lower, maybe two. The market moves away, and the trade is missed.
It is a classic perfectionist trap. The difference between the actual and ideal entry is tiny compared with the profit at stake, yet the desire for a perfect price blocks the trade.
Scalpers feel it keenly because every fraction of a pip is a visible share of the target. Waiting seems rational until the pattern shows up in the log: the missed trades are the winners, and the filled limit orders are disproportionately losers.
That is partly adverse selection. A limit order fills when price comes back, which often means the setup is failing. A market order fills immediately, in setups that are working.
The log can answer the question. Compare the results of trades taken at market with those taken on better-price limits, including the ones that never filled.
A rule that cuts through it: if the setup is valid at the market price and the cost of waiting is more than a quarter of the target, take the market price.
Has the quest for a better entry cost more than it saved?
Over-optimising the entry by one tick
Over-optimising the entry by one tick
It’s Fairman 
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Over-optimising the entry by one tick
The adverse selection point is the real core of this. A resting limit a tick better than market gets filled most reliably when price is moving against the idea, and least reliably when the setup works straight away. So the "saved" tick on filled trades is often paid for many times over by the winners that never filled. Judging the limit approach only by its filled trades makes it look far better than it is.
To measure it properly, log every valid signal at the moment it appears, with the market price available then, and track what that trade would have done whether or not it filled. Then compare three groups: market entries, filled limits, and unfilled limits. Include spread and commission on all of them, and look at expectancy per signal rather than per filled trade.
If waiting still seems worth it, set a hard time limit on the order, such as one or two bars, and cancel it once that expires. Another option is splitting size between market and limit. Either way, the rule should be decided in advance, not adjusted mid-trade.
To measure it properly, log every valid signal at the moment it appears, with the market price available then, and track what that trade would have done whether or not it filled. Then compare three groups: market entries, filled limits, and unfilled limits. Include spread and commission on all of them, and look at expectancy per signal rather than per filled trade.
If waiting still seems worth it, set a hard time limit on the order, such as one or two bars, and cancel it once that expires. Another option is splitting size between market and limit. Either way, the rule should be decided in advance, not adjusted mid-trade.