Candle colour is a lazy summary
A green candle means the close was above the open. That says nothing about how it got there.
A green candle that spent most of its life below the open and rallied in the final seconds is not the same as one that climbed steadily. The first signals buyers stepping in late. The second signals steady demand.
Scalpers working with candle patterns, engulfing bars, pin bars, and the like are reading summaries. The same pattern can come from very different underlying paths.
A way to add information is to look at how much time the price spent in each part of the candle. A close near the high after spending most of the time near the low is a different animal from a close near the high after hugging it all along.
Some traders compute the time-weighted average price within a bar and compare it with the close. The gap tells where the bar's real centre of gravity was.
It is extra work, but it shows how much a simple colour hides.
Does the strategy treat all green candles the same, regardless of how they formed?
Candle colour is a lazy summary
Candle colour is a lazy summary
It’s Fairman 
-
FXS London Scalper
- Posts: 975
- Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm
Re: Candle colour is a lazy summary
Looking at wick lengths and where the close sits within the range gives more information than colour. A close near the high after a long lower wick tells a different story from a small-bodied green candle that drifted up all minute.
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
Re: Candle colour is a lazy summary
Wick length does help, but I'd be careful about treating it as a substitute for the path. A long lower wick tells you price was rejected from somewhere, yet it doesn't say whether the bar spent 50 seconds down there or 5. Two M1 candles with the same wick and the same close can be a slow grind off the low versus a single spike and snap-back, and the second one is much more likely to be a thin-liquidity blip than real buying.
What I do in practice is a cheap proxy rather than a full time-weighted average. I look at where the close sits in the range and also where the midpoint of the bar sits relative to the open and close. If the close is near the high but the typical price for the bar was down near the low, I read it as late buying and don't chase it. If the bar hugged the high the whole way, I give it more credit. It's rough, but it stops me from lumping every green candle together, which is exactly the problem in the original post.
What I do in practice is a cheap proxy rather than a full time-weighted average. I look at where the close sits in the range and also where the midpoint of the bar sits relative to the open and close. If the close is near the high but the typical price for the bar was down near the low, I read it as late buying and don't chase it. If the bar hugged the high the whole way, I give it more credit. It's rough, but it stops me from lumping every green candle together, which is exactly the problem in the original post.
It’s Fairman 