Same gold short, same structure, two very different stops. In the London morning the wick I have to clear might be $8 or $10. In the London-New York overlap it can be $18 or $24. If I keep the same lot, I am no longer taking the same risk.
The schematic is that comparison. Both sides use a short from 4,038. On the left, the sweep wick goes to 4,048 and I put the stop at 4,050, $12 beyond the entry. A 0.03 lot, 3 ounces, risks $36. Target at 4,002 is $36, a clean 3R. On the right, the overlap print of the same idea wicks to 4,058 and the stop that actually sits past it is 4,062, $24 from the entry. My broker steps in 0.01 lots. A 0.02 lot would be $48, which is over the $40 I allow. A 0.01 lot risks $24. That is the size I would use, and the same 4,002 target is then only 1.5R.
I don't make up the smaller risk by taking a second gold trade. I take the 0.01 lot or I pass. The structure can be identical and still not be the same trade once the wick doubles.
I cut gold size in the overlap because the wick I have to clear is often twice as wide
Re: I cut gold size in the overlap because the wick I have to clear is often twice as wide
The 0.01 lot step is the part people skip when they say they'll just size to $40. On a $24 stop, $40 would need about 0.016 lots, and I can't place that. So I either risk $24 with 0.01 or $48 with 0.02. I take $24. If that feels too small to bother with, that is useful information: maybe the overlap idea isn't worth doing on a $10,000 account at all, and I wait for a session where the stop fits the cap cleanly. I would rather do nothing than bump to $48 because $24 isn't enough.
It’s Fairman 
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: I cut gold size in the overlap because the wick I have to clear is often twice as wide
Sizing off the stop distance instead of keeping a fixed lot is exactly the right way to handle gold across sessions. The overlap brings in heavier volume from New York and often a data release or two, so sweeps reach further and the wick you need to clear can easily double. Keeping the same lot in that environment quietly doubles your risk while the chart looks identical.
The minimum lot step point is important and often overlooked. On a small account the rounding can be a bigger share of the risk than people realise, so rounding down and accepting a lower reward-to-risk ratio is the disciplined choice. Some traders deal with it by tightening the setup instead, waiting for a second retest after the initial overlap spike so the stop can sit behind a smaller, cleaner wick.
It would be worth tracking whether the overlap trades at 1.5R actually pay off over time, or whether they drag the expectancy down compared with the London morning versions. If they do, simply skipping that window could be the cleaner rule.
The minimum lot step point is important and often overlooked. On a small account the rounding can be a bigger share of the risk than people realise, so rounding down and accepting a lower reward-to-risk ratio is the disciplined choice. Some traders deal with it by tightening the setup instead, waiting for a second retest after the initial overlap spike so the stop can sit behind a smaller, cleaner wick.
It would be worth tracking whether the overlap trades at 1.5R actually pay off over time, or whether they drag the expectancy down compared with the London morning versions. If they do, simply skipping that window could be the cleaner rule.
Re: I cut gold size in the overlap because the wick I have to clear is often twice as wide
I also don't split the idea into two half-sized entries to sneak up to $40. Two 0.01 lots, same stop, is just 0.02 under another name, and I've paid the spread twice if I scale in. One ticket, one stop, at the size the wick allows. If I want more gold risk I have to take it on a tighter, earlier session where the invalidation is actually $12, not invent a second entry during the overlap because I didn't like the first lot. Scaling into gold during the overlap is how a $24 risk becomes a $48 risk while I tell myself I was being careful.
It’s Fairman 
Re: I cut gold size in the overlap because the wick I have to clear is often twice as wide
Gold is the extreme case, but I check wick width on GBPJPY in the overlap too. The yen crosses can widen in the same window. I don't automatically cut those in half the way I do gold, because a 24-pip GBPJPY stop is still a normal scalp stop, whereas a $24 gold stop is a different dollar amount per 0.01 lot. The rule is measure the wick, then size, not always half size after 13:00. Gold just happens to be where the difference is obvious. On a quiet overlap day I still measure first. I don't cut size out of habit if the wick is actually small.
It’s Fairman 
Re: I cut gold size in the overlap because the wick I have to clear is often twice as wide
I didn't pull the $12 versus $24 figures out of the air. I have a short note, a few weeks of overlap gold sweeps, with the wick from the equal highs to the extreme written down in dollars. Some days it's $14, some days it's $20-plus. The $24 on the schematic is a wide but realistic overlap case, not a claim that every overlap wick is exactly $24. If a particular afternoon only wicks $10, I size it like the morning. The session label is a hint, the wick is the input.
It’s Fairman 