Advertisement IC Markets

Should a scalper ever widen a stop once the trade is open?

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Should a scalper ever widen a stop once the trade is open?

Post by Shadow Trader »

Most trading rules say never move a stop further away, and for good reason. Widening a stop after entry is usually a way to avoid taking a loss that the original plan accepted. It turns a defined risk into an open-ended one, and it tends to happen at exactly the moment when judgment is worst, with price moving against you.

That said, it's worth asking whether there's ever a legitimate case, because thinking it through makes the rule easier to follow.

One argument people make is about volatility changing after entry, for example a stop placed during a quiet period that suddenly sits inside normal noise once the session opens. But the honest answer there is usually that the stop was placed badly for the time of day, and the fix belongs in the entry rules, not in an adjustment mid-trade.

Another is a news release that wasn't on the radar. Again, the cleaner fix is a rule to be flat before scheduled events, or to close the trade, rather than giving it more room.

The one case that holds up a bit better is when the stop was set too tight by mistake, like a typo or the wrong level, and is clearly not where the plan said it should go. Correcting an error back to the planned stop is different from widening a plan. Even then, the risk should be checked again, since the size was chosen for the wrong stop.

A simple test before any adjustment: would you open a new trade right now with this wider stop and this size? If the answer is no, the adjustment is about avoiding the loss, not managing the trade.

Is there anyone here who allows widening under specific written conditions? I'd be interested in how the rule is worded.
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Post Reply