Price improvement exists, and its absence says something
Honest execution has price improvement as often as slippage. A buy order might fill a tenth of a pip better than quoted. A stop might trigger and fill slightly better than the stop price because the market gapped in the right direction.
Look at fills over a month and count how many came in better than requested. In healthy conditions, that proportion is meaningful. Some brokers advertise it openly, and a few even report it in their execution statistics.
If positive slippage never happens, the first suspicion is rounding or routing that caps the fill at the quoted price. The cap protects the broker from giving anything away while negative slippage still passes through. It is a design choice and a legal one in most places, which is exactly why traders should look.
The way to find out is simple: compare the price on the order ticket with the fill price in the deal history for every trade. Two columns, subtract, count the signs.
A broker with symmetrical slippage and some price improvement is behaving like a real marketplace. A broker with zero improvement across several hundred fills is behaving like a wall.
What share of fills on the live account came in at a better price than requested?
Price improvement exists, and its absence says something
-
FXS HongKong Scalper
- Posts: 543
- Joined: Sat Oct 24, 2026 10:15 pm
Re: Price improvement exists, and its absence says something
Comparing positive and negative slippage counts is a simple test. If slippage is almost always negative, especially on stops, the broker's execution is asymmetric. That is worth knowing before scaling a strategy.
FXS Official Team | Hong Kong Session Desk
Re: Price improvement exists, and its absence says something
Exactly, and the stop side is where I would look first. On my own account the cleanest check was to pull every stop-out from the deal history for a month and split them into fills at the stop price, worse than the stop, and better than the stop. If a broker gaps in my favour on a buy limit but never on a stop, that is not the market being random, that is a rule somebody wrote. A few tenths of a pip on a 0.2 lot is small per trade, but over a few hundred fills it adds up to a real number, and it is the same number whether I scalp EURUSD or gold.FXS HongKong Scalper wrote: Sun Nov 15, 2026 11:07 amComparing positive and negative slippage counts is a simple test. If slippage is almost always negative, especially on stops, the broker's execution is asymmetric. That is worth knowing before scaling a strategy.
Two caveats so I don't oversell it. First, a handful of negative fills in a fast news candle proves nothing, so I leave the minutes around red-folder releases out of the sample. Second, a broker can show real price improvement on market orders and still be asymmetric on stops, so I count each order type separately instead of one blended slippage figure. If the improvement count is zero across a few hundred fills in normal conditions while the negative ones keep coming, I treat the account as capped and I move size elsewhere.
It’s Fairman 