Document your personal trading journey. Track daily equity curves, review winning and losing streaks, share trade screenshots, and get constructive feedback.
Half of the arguments on this forum would be settled by data instead of opinion. Is the London open better than New York for EURUSD scalps? Does slippage really get worse on Fridays? Right now we each have a sample of one.
Proposal, strictly opt-in:
Each volunteer exports closed trades from MT4/MT5 or cTrader as CSV.
Before sharing, you strip account number, broker name if you want, and round open/close times to the minute.
Columns we'd keep: symbol, direction, open time (UTC), duration in seconds, entry spread, slippage in points, result in R.
Someone (I'm happy to do it) merges the files and posts aggregate tables only. No individual rows published.
Even with 10 traders and 300 trades each, that's 3,000 data points. Enough to see whether some of our beliefs hold up.
The obvious problems: different strategies, different brokers, survivorship (people with bad months won't share). I don't think it has to be perfect to be more useful than what we have now.
Would anyone join? And which column would you add or remove before it's worth your time?
This would genuinely settle a lot of arguments, and the privacy thinking in the proposal is careful. Rounding the times and stripping account numbers makes it hard to identify anyone from a single row, and only publishing aggregates helps even more.
A few things that might make the pooled data more useful:
Agree on the definition of R before anyone exports anything. Some traders define R from the initial stop, others from the stop after a partial close, and some don't use a fixed stop at all. If the definitions differ, the merged R figures will be hard to compare.
Record the strategy type in a broad category, such as breakout, fade, news or trend pullback. Without that, a result like "the London open is better" might really mean "breakout trades are better", which is a different conclusion.
Report sample sizes and the number of contributing traders for every table. If one active trader contributes 70 percent of the trades in a cell, the result mostly describes that one person.
Be careful with selection effects. People who volunteer their trades are probably more organised, and possibly more successful, than average, so the pooled numbers may not describe the typical trader on the forum.
Even with those limits, ten traders with a few hundred trades each is a lot more than anyone's sample of one. Questions about slippage by day of week or spread by hour are a good fit, because they depend more on the market and the broker than on the individual's skill.