Advertisement IC Markets

Tagging trades by setup quality A, B, C: how to set it up

Document your personal trading journey. Track daily equity curves, review winning and losing streaks, share trade screenshots, and get constructive feedback.
Post Reply
FXS London Scalper
Posts: 975
Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm

Tagging trades by setup quality A, B, C: how to set it up

Post by FXS London Scalper »

Tagging every trade at entry as A, B or C quality is one of the simplest journal changes with a clear payoff. It uses a short checklist: trend alignment on M15, a clean level, normal spread, no news nearby. A means all four, B three, C two or fewer.

After a few hundred trades, compute for each grade: share of all trades, expectancy in R, and number of trades.

What a typical result might look like, as an illustration:
  • A trades: 38% of the total, expectancy +0.3R.
  • B trades: 44%, around +0.05R.
  • C trades: 18%, clearly negative.
If yours looks like that, the decisions follow. C trades go first. B trades are harder: slightly positive and adding volume, but taking attention away from A setups.

Two things keep the test honest:
  • Tag at entry, never after. Grading after the result is useless.
  • Watch for bias on borderline cases. Even tagging at entry, it's easy to rate a trade higher when you really want to take it. Having a script compute the checklist removes that.
Has anyone graded trades like this for a long period? Did the gap between grades hold up over time?
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Tagging trades by setup quality A, B, C: how to set it up

Post by Shadow Trader »

The illustration of B trades being slightly positive but taking attention from A setups is the part that most people would find hardest to act on. Cutting C trades is an easy decision once the numbers show they're negative. B trades are a genuine trade-off.

One way to think about the B group is to look at what was happening at the same time. If B trades often appear while an A setup is forming or already open on another pair, they're competing for attention and probably costing more than their small positive expectancy suggests. If they mostly appear at times when there's no A setup around, they're adding volume without much cost, and keeping them may make sense.

Another useful split is by which condition was missing. A B trade that's missing the trend alignment is a different kind of trade from one that's missing the clean level, and the two groups can behave quite differently. Breaking the B grade down by the missing item often shows that one version is close to an A trade and the other is close to a C.

The other caution is about grading honestly at entry rather than afterwards. After a winner it's very tempting to remember the setup as an A. A simple way to protect against that is to enter the grade before the trade is placed, or at least in the same minute, and never change it later. Without that, the grades slowly drift towards whatever the result was, and the analysis stops meaning anything.
Post Reply