Advertisement IC Markets

Stop hunting or thin liquidity? A way to check your own stop fills

Compare ECN/Raw spread brokers, analyze execution speeds, report slippage, and evaluate commission structures for high-frequency traders.
Post Reply
FXS London Scalper
Posts: 975
Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm

Stop hunting or thin liquidity? A way to check your own stop fills

Post by FXS London Scalper »

Many traders suspect their broker of hunting stops. It's possible to check with your own data instead of guessing.

Method, over a few months:
  • Log every stop loss: time, stop level, fill price, slippage.
  • Check whether price on another feed, for example a second broker or a futures chart, reached the same level.
  • Note if the stop sat at a level many traders would pick, like a round number or a recent high or low.
  • Note the time: open, news, rollover or quiet.
How to read it:
  • If stops trigger where other feeds also traded, it's the market.
  • If they cluster at rollover or opens with wide spreads, it's liquidity and spread, which is real but not targeting.
  • If stops trigger on your broker's feed only, repeatedly, at quiet times, that's worth raising with the broker, with examples.
A common finding is that stops at obvious levels get hit more often simply because many traders use them.

Has anyone done this comparison?
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Stop hunting or thin liquidity? A way to check your own stop fills

Post by Shadow Trader »

This is a really useful way to turn a suspicion into something you can actually look at. The second-feed comparison is the key part, because without it every stop that gets taken at the high of a spike feels personal.

One thing I'd add to the method is recording the spread at the moment the stop triggered, not just the fill price. On a buy position your stop is hit on the bid, but most charts show the bid only, so a long stop behaves the way you'd expect. On a sell position the stop is triggered by the ask, and if the spread jumps from 0.2 to 2 pips at rollover, the ask can touch your stop while the bid line on the chart never gets near it. That looks exactly like a stop hunt on the chart, but it's really a spread event. Splitting the log into long stops and short stops can show this quite clearly, because a broker problem would hit both sides while a spread problem mostly shows up on shorts.

The other useful check is distance. If the stops that look suspicious are mostly the tight ones, just a few pips from entry, then the issue is usually that the stop was inside normal noise for that time of day rather than anyone targeting it.

If the pattern still holds after accounting for spread and distance, and it only happens on one broker's feed, then it's worth raising with the broker with the data in hand. That conversation goes much better with a spreadsheet than with a screenshot.
Post Reply