A test that's useful for any strategy: could another trader follow your written rules and take the same trades you would? If the answer is no, the strategy isn't fully defined, and part of it lives in your head.
That isn't necessarily a problem, since discretion can be valuable. But undefined parts are where inconsistency creeps in. On a good day you might read a level one way, on a tired day another, and the results become hard to interpret because they mix the strategy with your mood.
Writing it down with that standard in mind tends to expose the gaps quickly. A few areas that often turn out to be vague:
What counts as a level. "A clear support" means different things to different people. Is it a swing low with a certain number of candles on each side, a previous day's low, a round number?
When the entry is triggered. On a candle close, a break of a high, a limit order at a price? And what if price moves past the entry before the order is filled?
Where the stop and target go, exactly, and what happens if the spread is wider than normal.
What stops you trading. Time of day, news, number of trades, daily loss.
Once it's written, one way to check it is to go through a week of charts and mark every trade the rules allow, without looking at the outcome first. If you find yourself wanting to skip or add trades, that's where the rules need more work, or where you've identified a genuine discretionary element worth recording separately.
Has anyone tried having someone else trade from their written rules? It seems like it would be an eye-opening exercise.
Writing a strategy down so that someone else could trade it
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm