Advertisement IC Markets

How many rules should a scalping strategy have?

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

How many rules should a scalping strategy have?

Post by Shadow Trader »

There seem to be two common ways strategies end up. Some stay very simple, maybe three or four conditions for entry and a fixed exit. Others grow over time, with a filter added after every bad week, until there are fifteen conditions and the setup only appears twice a month.

Each extra rule usually comes from a real observation. A news filter is added after a loss during a release, a spread filter after a bad fill, a trend filter after a few losing counter-trend trades. The problem is that each rule also removes some good trades, and with enough filters it becomes almost impossible to tell whether the strategy has an edge or is just fitted to the last few months.

A couple of questions can help decide whether a rule belongs:

Is there a reason for it that doesn't depend on recent results? A spread filter makes sense on cost grounds alone. A rule like "don't trade on the third Tuesday" probably doesn't.

Does it improve results across different periods, not just the one that prompted it? If a filter only helps in the months where it was discovered, it's probably curve fitting.

Can you apply it consistently in real time? A rule that requires judgement, like "only when the market feels strong", tends to be followed when it's convenient and ignored otherwise.

There's also a practical limit. Under pressure, people forget rules, so a strategy with many conditions is more likely to be traded inconsistently, which can be worse than having a simpler set that's followed every time.

How many rules does your main setup have, and have you ever improved a strategy by removing rules rather than adding them?
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Post Reply