Why price moves against you right after a fill
A common complaint is that price turns just after an entry. The feeling is that the market knows. The cause is more mundane and has a name: adverse selection.
When a liquidity provider fills an order, the provider's quote reflects its view of fair value. A buy order at the ask gets filled only if the provider is willing to sell at that price. If the provider has information, or a model suggesting the price is about to fall, it's happy to sell. The trade that gets filled is, on average, the one that works out slightly worse for the buyer.
Last look amplifies this. Orders that would have been profitable get rejected more often, and the unprofitable ones get filled. The fills that remain skew toward losers.
The effect is small, a fraction of a pip on average, but it's systematic. It explains why live results often trail backtests, which assume every signal is filled.
Measuring it requires data: compare the mid-price at the moment of fill with the mid-price one second and ten seconds later. If the price tends to move against the position after the fill, adverse selection is at work.
One second after a fill, which way does the average price lean in the logs?
Why price moves against you right after a fill
Why price moves against you right after a fill
It’s Fairman 
-
FXS London Scalper
- Posts: 976
- Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm
Re: Why price moves against you right after a fill
The mundane explanation is the right one, and it suggests a test. If the move against the fill is mostly adverse selection, it should be worse on entries taken in fast markets than on resting limits in quiet ones. Splitting the first 10 seconds after each fill by entry type usually shows which entries carry the cost.
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
Re: Why price moves against you right after a fill
FXS London Scalper wrote: Sun Nov 08, 2026 11:05 amThe mundane explanation is the right one, and it suggests a test. If the move against the fill is mostly adverse selection, it should be worse on entries taken in fast markets than on resting limits in quiet ones. Splitting the first 10 seconds after each fill by entry type usually shows which entries carry the cost.
The split by entry type is the useful part. A single average of the first second or the first ten seconds only tells you that something leans against the fill. It does not tell you which kind of order is paying for it.
I would not assume the cost is always worse on fast-market entries than on resting limits in quiet conditions. They fail for different reasons. A market order in a busy spread is where last look and stale quotes show up: the fill happens when the other side is willing, and the next few seconds often drip against you. A limit sitting in a quiet book gets filled because price came to it, which often means the move has already started through that level. That can look small in a ten-second window, or it can look sharp, depending on how fast the pickup was. The test still works; the result just should not be prejudged.
The other thing that muddies the comparison is mixed labels. If a limit gets pulled and replaced into a spike, it is no longer a quiet resting order. If a market order goes in during a dead stretch after lunch, it is not a fast-market fill. Tagging each fill with the entry type, the spread at the moment of fill, and whether the tape was already running keeps the two buckets honest. Then the +1s and +10s mid-to-mid change inside each bucket usually shows where the cost actually sits.
It’s Fairman 
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Why price moves against you right after a fill
Tagging by entry type, spread and tape speed makes sense, and it might be worth adding one more dimension: where the entry sits relative to recent structure. A buy limit resting just above a level that price is falling into often fills because sellers are pushing through, so the adverse move after the fill is the continuation of a real move, not the provider picking you off. A market buy into a spike at a fresh high has a different problem, which is chasing a move that is already exhausted for that moment.
The +1s and +10s comparison is a good pair because they separate two effects. Drift at one second is mostly execution and microstructure, while drift at ten seconds says more about whether the signal itself is early or late. If the one second number is bad but ten seconds recovers, the setup is fine and the entry method is the issue. If both are bad, the signal needs work.
A common mistake is using bid for buys and ask for sells when measuring, which bakes the spread into every result. Mid to mid, as suggested, keeps it clean, and the spread can then be reviewed as a separate cost line.
The +1s and +10s comparison is a good pair because they separate two effects. Drift at one second is mostly execution and microstructure, while drift at ten seconds says more about whether the signal itself is early or late. If the one second number is bad but ten seconds recovers, the setup is fine and the entry method is the issue. If both are bad, the signal needs work.
A common mistake is using bid for buys and ask for sells when measuring, which bakes the spread into every result. Mid to mid, as suggested, keeps it clean, and the spread can then be reviewed as a separate cost line.