Advertisement IC Markets

Why a strategy's average trade matters more than its win rate

Discuss 1-minute to 15-minute price action setups, fading intraday momentum, key support/resistance zones, and proven short-term trading methodologies.
Post Reply
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Why a strategy's average trade matters more than its win rate

Post by Shadow Trader »

Win rate is the number people quote first, but on its own it says almost nothing about whether a strategy makes money. The average result per trade, after costs, says much more.

A quick comparison shows why. A strategy that wins 75% of the time with an average win of 3 pips and an average loss of 10 pips has an average trade of 0.75 x 3 - 0.25 x 10, which is minus 0.25 pips. A strategy that wins 40% with an average win of 9 pips and an average loss of 4 has an average trade of 0.4 x 9 - 0.6 x 4, which is plus 1.2 pips. The first one feels much better to trade and loses money.

For scalpers the average trade has another important use: it shows how much room there is for costs. If the average trade before costs is 1.5 pips and the combined spread, commission and slippage come to 1 pip, then 2/3 of the edge goes to costs. Any small increase in spread, or a slightly worse fill, wipes out the rest. A strategy with an average trade of 5 pips before costs is far more robust to the same conditions.

It's worth looking at a few related numbers alongside it:

Average trade in pips and in R, after all costs.
How the average trade changes by session and by pair.
How many trades the average is based on, since a few big outliers can carry a small sample.

If someone shares a strategy with an impressive win rate and no average trade figure, that's the first question to ask.

What figures do people here check first when they look at a strategy's results?
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
Post Reply