When liquidity providers pull their quotes
Market makers do not like uncertainty. When a big number is about to land, many of them simply stop quoting, or widen their prices so far that nobody trades. That is the reason for the odd gaps in a news chart.
On the screen it looks like price jumping from one level to another with nothing in between. In reality there were no prices in between. Orders that were sitting in that range get filled at the next available quote, which may be far away.
Stop losses are the main victims. A stop at 15 pips from entry can fill at 40 because the market skipped over the level entirely. Brokers call this slippage, and in this situation it is not a failure of the system. It is how the market works.
Limit orders can benefit, since a spike through a limit price often fills at the limit or better. That is one reason some traders prefer pending orders near news over stops.
Protection comes mainly from size. A position small enough to survive a gap through the stop is the only reliable defence.
Orders placed as limits near the expected reaction zone can benefit from the gaps, since a fast move through the limit price often fills at the limit or better. Many experienced news scalpers prefer this to stops for exactly that reason.
Has a stop ever filled much further away than expected during a data release?
When liquidity providers pull their quotes
When liquidity providers pull their quotes
It’s Fairman 
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: When liquidity providers pull their quotes
A useful distinction is that a stop normally becomes a market order once triggered, so a thin book can leave it filled well beyond the stop level. A limit order caps the acceptable price, but that protection comes with the possibility of no fill at all if price jumps through and liquidity disappears. Neither order type guarantees a clean news entry.
For a fair comparison, log the release time, bid and ask before and after it, the order type, requested price, fill price and any rejection. Separate ordinary slippage from a quote gap; the trade history alone can hide whether the trigger was reached on bid or ask.
I’d test the setup with worst-case gap assumptions before sizing it, not just the average spread. If the position cannot tolerate a move well past the stop, reducing exposure or staying flat through the release is more reliable than treating a pending limit as a hedge.
For a fair comparison, log the release time, bid and ask before and after it, the order type, requested price, fill price and any rejection. Separate ordinary slippage from a quote gap; the trade history alone can hide whether the trigger was reached on bid or ask.
I’d test the setup with worst-case gap assumptions before sizing it, not just the average spread. If the position cannot tolerate a move well past the stop, reducing exposure or staying flat through the release is more reliable than treating a pending limit as a hedge.
-
FXS London Scalper
- Posts: 976
- Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm
Re: When liquidity providers pull their quotes
Any stop sitting close to price in the first seconds of a release can be filled at whatever level the first returning provider quotes. Removing tight stops beforehand, or being flat, avoids that gap, while a pending limit order can benefit from the same spike, as the post notes, if its fill risk is accepted.
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
Re: When liquidity providers pull their quotes
Agree on being flat, but I'd be careful with the "remove tight stops" half. Pulling the stop and staying in means the position has no exit at all through the release, which is worse than a bad fill. If I'm holding through a number, I size it as if the stop will fill three times further away than where it sits.FXS London Scalper wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:28 pmAny stop sitting close to price in the first seconds of a release can be filled at whatever level the first returning provider quotes. Removing tight stops beforehand, or being flat, avoids that gap, while a pending limit order can benefit from the same spike, as the post notes, if its fill risk is accepted.
Worked example on a $10,000 account risking 0.5%, so $50. Stop 10 pips away, normal size would be 0.50 lot on EURUSD. If I assume a gap out to 30 pips, 0.50 lot loses $150, which is 1.5% instead of 0.5%. So for the release I cut to about 0.16 lot. At 10 pips that only risks $16, and if it does gap to 30 the loss is $48, still inside the plan.
On the limit side, the catch Amanhasnoname raised still stands: the spike fill is nice when you get it, but price can jump straight through with no fill, so I don't build the sizing around it.
It’s Fairman 