Here's a question I don't see discussed much. You enter a scalp, it doesn't hit your stop, doesn't hit your target, and just drifts sideways a couple of pips either side of your entry. How long do you give it?
It's tempting to give these trades as much time as they need, on the basis that the stop and target were the plan and anything else is interference. The problem is that the longer a scalp sits there, the worse the outcome tends to be. My view is that trades that haven't moved meaningfully in your direction within the first five minutes are a weaker group, and the losses on those slow trades are often full stop-outs that come after a long wait.
It makes sense when you think about it. If you're entering on a burst of momentum or a reaction from a level, the idea is that something should happen soon. If nothing happens, the reason for the trade has probably faded, and you're now holding a random position with a stop attached.
So a time limit that depends on the setup is worth considering. For momentum entries, about five minutes. For level reactions, about ten. If the trade hasn't made progress by then, close at market, whatever the P&L. Plenty of those exits end up being small wins or tiny losses that would have become full losses.
Do others use time stops on scalps, or do you just let the price levels decide?
How long should a scalp be allowed to do nothing?
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm