For years the usual advice has been the top-down routine. Check the daily, mark the H4 levels, decide on a bias, then drop to M1 and M5 for entries in that direction. It's worth asking whether all that is actually helping, and one way to test it is to trade purely off the M5 chart for a stretch, with no idea what the bigger picture is doing.
You might expect that to go badly. I'm not sure it would, at least not in the way people think. The M5 setup is still the M5 setup, so the win rate may not change much. What I'd expect to change is the size of the winners. With a higher-timeframe bias, the best trades are the ones that run with the bigger trend, and they can go a long way. Without that filter, you take more trades against the trend that work as scalps but rarely extend.
The other effect is how much calmer the sessions can feel. Without a bias, you're not fighting the chart when it goes against your view. You just trade what is in front of you.
So the conclusion I'd come to is somewhere in the middle. The higher timeframe isn't telling you which way to trade so much as which trades are allowed to run. Marking the daily levels still makes sense, but you can take setups in both directions and only let the trend-direction trades go for the bigger targets.
I'd be curious if anyone else has tried something like this.
Do scalps still work if you ignore the higher timeframe?
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm