Markouts: the audit that exposes everything
A markout measures how the price moves after a trade. Take each fill, note the mid-price at that moment, and record the mid-price 1, 5, 10, and 60 seconds later. Average the differences, signed by direction.
If the strategy is genuinely good, the markouts are positive, and they grow over time. If the entries are mistimed, the markouts are negative at short horizons.
The pattern at each horizon says something specific. A positive markout at 60 seconds but negative at 1 second means the entries are early: price dips first and then moves in the intended direction. A positive at 1 second that fades by 60 means the signal catches a quick impulse that decays.
Comparing markouts between sessions or pairs highlights where the strategy has edge and where it doesn't. It also shows how costly slippage is.
It's a standard tool at institutional trading desks. Few retail traders use it, yet the data needed is simple: fills and a tick history.
Even a basic spreadsheet markout table gives a clearer picture of execution quality than win rate does.
For the entries in the journal, what do the one-second and ten-second markouts say?
Markouts: the audit that exposes everything
Markouts: the audit that exposes everything
It’s Fairman 
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1689
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Markouts: the audit that exposes everything
Mid-price at 1, 5, 10 and 60 seconds after each fill is about as honest an audit as exists. A negative 1-second markout with a positive 60-second one says the direction is right and the entries are early; negative at every horizon says there's no edge, whatever the P&L of the last month suggests.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Markouts: the audit that exposes everything
I ran this on my own journal last winter after a month where the P&L looked fine but something felt off. I only had my fills and a tick export from the platform, so I kept it simple and measured the mid at 1, 10 and 60 seconds after each entry, nothing fancier than a spreadsheet with a lookup column.
The one-second numbers were negative on almost every pair, roughly a fifth of a pip against me on average. By ten seconds they were slightly positive and by sixty seconds clearly positive. So the direction was right, but I was buying into the little push that comes just before a pullback. Waiting for the first retrace after the signal, instead of clicking on the signal candle itself, moved the short horizon close to flat.
The surprise was the split by session. The Asian session trades had negative markouts at every horizon, which meant the small profits there were mostly luck. I stopped trading that window entirely, and the monthly numbers got steadier.
The one-second numbers were negative on almost every pair, roughly a fifth of a pip against me on average. By ten seconds they were slightly positive and by sixty seconds clearly positive. So the direction was right, but I was buying into the little push that comes just before a pullback. Waiting for the first retrace after the signal, instead of clicking on the signal candle itself, moved the short horizon close to flat.
The surprise was the split by session. The Asian session trades had negative markouts at every horizon, which meant the small profits there were mostly luck. I stopped trading that window entirely, and the monthly numbers got steadier.
Re: Markouts: the audit that exposes everything
Negative at every horizon is the harsh case, and it's worth separating it from one that only looks similar. If the 1-second markout is -0.3 pips, the 10-second -0.2 and the 60-second -0.1, the line is still below zero but climbing, which usually points to late entries into a move that partly works rather than no edge at all. Flat at -0.3 across all four horizons is the one I'd call dead.FXS Prop Desk wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:25 am Mid-price at 1, 5, 10 and 60 seconds after each fill is about as honest an audit as exists. A negative 1-second markout with a positive 60-second one says the direction is right and the entries are early; negative at every horizon says there's no edge, whatever the P&L of the last month suggests.
Sample size matters as well. With 40 fills and a per-trade markout standard deviation of around 1.5 pips, the standard error is roughly 0.24 pips, so a -0.2 average can't be told apart from zero yet. At 400 fills that error drops to about 0.075, and a -0.2 reading starts to mean something.
I'd also split by entry type before writing a strategy off. Limit fills and market fills often show opposite signs at short horizons, and averaging them together can bury a decent half under a poor one.
It’s Fairman 