Commission versus spread: the maths most traders skip
A raw spread account with a commission looks cheaper than a standard account with a wider spread. Often it is. But the comparison is usually done on the advertised average, which is the wrong number.
Take a standard account at 1.2 pips average on EURUSD and a raw account at 0.1 pip plus 7 dollars round turn per lot. At a 7 dollar commission the raw account costs about 0.7 pip equivalent, so the total is 0.8. Cheaper, apparently.
Now factor in what actually happens. Raw spreads blow out more at rollover and during news. The standard account's spread is smoother, because the markup absorbs swings. During a particular hour the raw account might be paying 1.5 pips plus commission while the standard sits at 1.8. Over a full day the gap narrows or flips.
The honest comparison needs the average cost per trade at the exact times the strategy trades. Not the whole day. Not the advertised figure.
Method: export a month of trades, multiply lots by the commission, add the spread paid at entry time from tick data or from the platform's history, and divide by trades. One number, and it is probably different from the marketing.
Which account type came out cheaper after doing the calculation for the specific trading hours?
Commission versus spread: the maths most traders skip
Re: Commission versus spread: the maths most traders skip
The account type that comes out cheaper is entirely dictated by the strategy’s operating hours and trade duration, meaning the "winner" splits cleanly into two distinct operational profiles rather than a single universal answer.
If a strategy executes during peak liquidity (the London/New York overlap), the Raw spread account is mathematically cheaper. If the strategy executes during market open, 5:00 PM EST rollover, or major news events (NFP, CPI), the Standard account frequently costs less because the broker's markup acts as a buffer against institutional liquidity gaps.
If a strategy executes during peak liquidity (the London/New York overlap), the Raw spread account is mathematically cheaper. If the strategy executes during market open, 5:00 PM EST rollover, or major news events (NFP, CPI), the Standard account frequently costs less because the broker's markup acts as a buffer against institutional liquidity gaps.
Preserve your own money. Scale with the market's money. Exponential growth is the ultimate key.
Re: Commission versus spread: the maths most traders skip
The Liquidity Disconnect
The advertised average spread is a 24-hour mathematical mean. It includes hours where liquidity providers flood the market and hours where they pull their orders entirely.
Raw accounts pass the interbank spread directly to the trader. When institutional liquidity dries up (e.g., at the daily rollover), the raw interbank spread can widen aggressively from 0.1 pips to 2.0 or 3.0 pips. A Standard account is synthetically smoothed by the broker. The broker widens the standard spread during these times as well, but often less aggressively than the raw feed gaps, because the baseline 1.2 pip markup already prices in a degree of execution risk.
The advertised average spread is a 24-hour mathematical mean. It includes hours where liquidity providers flood the market and hours where they pull their orders entirely.
Raw accounts pass the interbank spread directly to the trader. When institutional liquidity dries up (e.g., at the daily rollover), the raw interbank spread can widen aggressively from 0.1 pips to 2.0 or 3.0 pips. A Standard account is synthetically smoothed by the broker. The broker widens the standard spread during these times as well, but often less aggressively than the raw feed gaps, because the baseline 1.2 pip markup already prices in a degree of execution risk.
Preserve your own money. Scale with the market's money. Exponential growth is the ultimate key.
Re: Commission versus spread: the maths most traders skip
The Missing Variables in the Export Method
To truly execute the exact-hour calculation method you described, you must also account for two additional hidden costs that do not show up in a simple spread export:
Slippage Asymmetry: Raw accounts route directly to liquidity providers (ECN/STP execution). If the market moves during the milliseconds your order is processed, you suffer negative slippage. Standard accounts (often market makers) may guarantee the quoted price (instant execution) but will deliver a requote instead of slippage. A 0.5 pip slippage on a Raw account instantly erases its spread advantage for that trade.
Commission on Stop Losses: If your strategy scales out of positions or gets stopped out frequently in fractional lots, the commission is charged round-turn regardless of the outcome. Standard accounts only charge the spread on the exact entry/exit prices hit.
To truly execute the exact-hour calculation method you described, you must also account for two additional hidden costs that do not show up in a simple spread export:
Slippage Asymmetry: Raw accounts route directly to liquidity providers (ECN/STP execution). If the market moves during the milliseconds your order is processed, you suffer negative slippage. Standard accounts (often market makers) may guarantee the quoted price (instant execution) but will deliver a requote instead of slippage. A 0.5 pip slippage on a Raw account instantly erases its spread advantage for that trade.
Commission on Stop Losses: If your strategy scales out of positions or gets stopped out frequently in fractional lots, the commission is charged round-turn regardless of the outcome. Standard accounts only charge the spread on the exact entry/exit prices hit.
Preserve your own money. Scale with the market's money. Exponential growth is the ultimate key.
Re: Commission versus spread: the maths most traders skip
Baseline Math Verification
To verify the foundational premise presented in your scenario:
One standard lot of EURUSD equals 100,000 units. The pip value is strictly $10 per pip.
A round-turn commission of $7 translates to $7 / $10 = 0.7 pips.
Adding the raw spread: 0.1 pips + 0.7 pips = 0.8 pips total cost.
Comparing this to the Standard account's 1.2 pips total cost.
The calculation of 0.8 pips vs 1.2 pips is accurate for baseline peak-hour conditions. The Raw account is fundamentally cheaper during high-liquidity hours, while the Standard account becomes the cheaper option for off-hours, rollover, and news-based execution.
To verify the foundational premise presented in your scenario:
One standard lot of EURUSD equals 100,000 units. The pip value is strictly $10 per pip.
A round-turn commission of $7 translates to $7 / $10 = 0.7 pips.
Adding the raw spread: 0.1 pips + 0.7 pips = 0.8 pips total cost.
Comparing this to the Standard account's 1.2 pips total cost.
The calculation of 0.8 pips vs 1.2 pips is accurate for baseline peak-hour conditions. The Raw account is fundamentally cheaper during high-liquidity hours, while the Standard account becomes the cheaper option for off-hours, rollover, and news-based execution.
Preserve your own money. Scale with the market's money. Exponential growth is the ultimate key.