Advertisement IC Markets

Requotes then, slippage now: how execution costs changed shape

Compare ECN/Raw spread brokers, analyze execution speeds, report slippage, and evaluate commission structures for high-frequency traders.
Post Reply
FXS London Scalper
Posts: 976
Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm

Requotes then, slippage now: how execution costs changed shape

Post by FXS London Scalper »

Older traders remember market maker accounts where requotes in the first minutes after 08:00 were routine. Today most retail accounts use market execution with slippage instead. The cost hasn't disappeared; it has changed shape.

The old model:
  • Your order came back with a new price, usually worse, and you accepted or rejected it.
  • You saw the cost every time, which was annoying but transparent.
  • Requotes in your favour were rare.
The current model:
  • No requotes, because the order fills at the available price.
  • Slippage shows up only in the fill, and can be positive or negative.
  • Fill times are typically tens of milliseconds rather than hundreds.
The risk now is that slippage is quiet. Unless you log requested price against fill price, you won't notice it. A worked example: if a third of your open-time orders slip by an average of 0.2 pips, that's about 0.07 pips per order across all of them. Relative to a 5 pip target it's minor, but on 400 trades it is 28 pips.

To compare the two models on your own account, export the deal history, compute fill minus requested price, and group by the minute after 08:00.

Does anyone still use an account that requotes? Some traders prefer seeing the price before accepting it.
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
PTScalper
Site Admin
Posts: 7821
Joined: Mon Jul 20, 2026 1:28 pm

Re: Requotes then, slippage now: how execution costs changed shape

Post by PTScalper »

FXS London Scalper wrote: Fri Oct 30, 2026 12:59 pm Older traders remember market maker accounts where requotes in the first minutes after 08:00 were routine. Today most retail accounts use market execution with slippage instead. The cost hasn't disappeared; it has changed shape.

The old model:
  • Your order came back with a new price, usually worse, and you accepted or rejected it.
  • You saw the cost every time, which was annoying but transparent.
  • Requotes in your favour were rare.
The current model:
  • No requotes, because the order fills at the available price.
  • Slippage shows up only in the fill, and can be positive or negative.
  • Fill times are typically tens of milliseconds rather than hundreds.
The risk now is that slippage is quiet. Unless you log requested price against fill price, you won't notice it. A worked example: if a third of your open-time orders slip by an average of 0.2 pips, that's about 0.07 pips per order across all of them. Relative to a 5 pip target it's minor, but on 400 trades it is 28 pips.

To compare the two models on your own account, export the deal history, compute fill minus requested price, and group by the minute after 08:00.

Does anyone still use an account that requotes? Some traders prefer seeing the price before accepting it.
Yeah,

The execution cost hasn’t disappeared; it has just been pushed off the visible spread and buried in the execution telemetry. When a retail trader is clicking 0.1 lots, that “0.0 pip” spread is real because top-of-book liquidity can easily absorb it. But as an account scales and pushes 10, 20, or 50 lots into the market, it immediately exposes the difference between a broker with a shallow B-book and a deep ECN aggregator like IC Markets.

With market execution, the order book acts as a ladder. If the top-of-book only holds 2 lots of liquidity at that 0.0 spread, a 15-lot market order will sweep the first level, then chew through the next three or four price levels to fill the remaining 13 lots. The broker then hands you a single Volume-Weighted Average Price (VWAP) fill. On a low-liquidity broker, that order book sweep creates heavy negative slippage—turning a theoretical 0.0 pip spread into a 0.8 or 1.5 pip effective cost. On a deep ECN, the institutional liquidity pool has enough volume at the top levels to absorb the larger size with minimal deviation. That’s why tracking the delta between requested price and fill price is mandatory for larger sizes; quiet slippage will bleed a scaled strategy to death without ever showing up as a commission.
Preserve your own money. Scale with the market's money. Exponential growth is the ultimate key.
PTScalper
Site Admin
Posts: 7821
Joined: Mon Jul 20, 2026 1:28 pm

Re: Requotes then, slippage now: how execution costs changed shape

Post by PTScalper »

To answer your question: virtually no one running serious size or automated strategies uses instant execution (requote) accounts anymore. There are three fatal flaws with the old requote model for modern trading:

The Latency Penalty: By the time a dealer requotes you and you manually click to accept, the market has already moved again. In a sub-100ms execution environment, human confirmation is a guaranteed loss of edge.

Asymmetric "Last Look": Requotes were notoriously one-sided. If the price moved in your favor, the dealing desk often filled it at the original quote. If it moved against them, they hit you with a requote.

Execution Certainty: When scaling out of a large position or hitting a stop-loss, you need the order to clear immediately. A requote rejection during high volatility leaves you holding naked risk.
Preserve your own money. Scale with the market's money. Exponential growth is the ultimate key.
PTScalper
Site Admin
Posts: 7821
Joined: Mon Jul 20, 2026 1:28 pm

Re: Requotes then, slippage now: how execution costs changed shape

Post by PTScalper »

Traders who still want price protection without the requote trap don't revert to instant execution. Instead, they use limit orders or configure a "maximum deviation" parameter on their market orders. This caps the acceptable slippage tolerance, ensuring the order drops if liquidity thins out too aggressively, without giving a dealing desk a free option to stall the trade.
Preserve your own money. Scale with the market's money. Exponential growth is the ultimate key.
Amanhasnoname
Posts: 2060
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am

Re: Requotes then, slippage now: how execution costs changed shape

Post by Amanhasnoname »

Yes, I still keep a small secondary account with instant execution for a couple of slower strategies, and I agree it is no good for anything fast. On my main account I switched to market execution years ago and never looked back, but the transparency of seeing a requote did teach me how often my entry price was shifting.

Since moving over, I set the deviation to 2 points on majors and log requested versus filled price for every order in a spreadsheet. After a few hundred orders I found my worst slippage clustered in the first two minutes after the London open and around 13:30 data releases, so I now delay entries by a minute or so at those times.

If someone prefers a requote account for the visibility, I would suggest they get the same visibility by logging fills on a market account. You get the data without giving a dealer the option to stall the order.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: Requotes then, slippage now: how execution costs changed shape

Post by Shadow Trader »

This is a good way to frame it. The cost didn't go away, it just moved from somewhere you could see it to somewhere you have to go looking for it.

One practical point that follows from this: with requotes you knew your cost the moment it happened, but with slippage you only find out by comparing the price you clicked with the price you got. Most platforms don't put those side by side. MT4 and MT5 both show the fill price, but the requested price isn't stored anywhere obvious, so unless you log it yourself the slippage simply vanishes into the results. A small script or even a manual note of the quoted price for a few dozen trades is usually enough to see whether the average is near zero or quietly negative.

It's also worth splitting the numbers by time of day and by order type. Market orders at the open and stop orders that trigger during a fast move tend to carry most of the negative slippage, while limit orders mostly avoid it but give up some fills. For a scalper whose average target is a handful of pips, a fraction of a pip of slippage on each side can be a big share of the edge, so this is one of the few costs that really is worth measuring rather than guessing at.
Post Reply