Most conversations treat slippage as a villain. Orders fill worse than expected, and everyone complains. The less discussed half is positive slippage, where orders fill at a better price than requested.
Whether a broker passes positive slippage to clients depends on its execution model. Some use symmetrical slippage, giving the benefit when price moves in the client's favour. Others only pass negative slippage through, a practice that quietly drains accounts over thousands of trades.
The test is simple. Open a demo or small live account and place 50 market orders during active hours. Log the difference between the requested price and the filled price. If every single deviation is negative, something is off. Real markets move both ways, so a fair broker should show a mix.
This matters more for scalpers than for swing traders, because a half pip of one-sided slippage on a 5 pip target is a 10 percent tax on every winner.
Has anyone run this test on their own broker, and what did the numbers show?
Slippage is not always a bad thing
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1689
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Slippage is not always a bad thing
The execution model decides it. A broker that only passes negative slippage has a cost hidden in every fast market. Asking for the broker's execution policy in writing, and checking the positive and negative split in the trade log, gives the answer.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Slippage is not always a bad thing
I ran roughly this test on a small live account a while back, and the result surprised me. Over sixty market orders in the London and New York overlap, about two thirds filled at the requested price, around a quarter filled slightly worse, and only a handful filled better. A fair mix should be more symmetric than that, so I took it as a warning sign.
What I found useful was logging the fill difference in tenths of a pip next to the time and the news calendar. Nearly all the bad fills clustered within a minute of data releases, which is understandable, but the lack of price improvement on quiet moves was what bothered me.
I ended up moving part of my volume to another broker and repeated the test there. The split looked more balanced, with better fills turning up about a third of the time, and my average cost on a five pip target dropped noticeably.
What I found useful was logging the fill difference in tenths of a pip next to the time and the news calendar. Nearly all the bad fills clustered within a minute of data releases, which is understandable, but the lack of price improvement on quiet moves was what bothered me.
I ended up moving part of my volume to another broker and repeated the test there. The split looked more balanced, with better fills turning up about a third of the time, and my average cost on a five pip target dropped noticeably.