Here's a detail that catches people. A buy position closes at the bid. A sell position closes at the ask. So stops on shorts trigger on the ask price.
When the spread widens, the ask jumps up even if the bid doesn't move. Picture a short with a stop 3 pips above entry during a thin moment. The spread goes from 0.5 to 4 pips. The ask touches the stop. The trade closes at a loss while the chart, which usually plots bid, shows nothing dramatic.
The trader stares at a candle that never reached the stop and wonders if the broker cheated. Usually it's just mechanics, though that doesn't make it feel better.
The workaround is to either enable the ask line on the chart, so the stop level can be seen against the real trigger price, or to avoid holding tight shorts in thin windows.
Has a stopped-out short ever looked impossible on the chart, and did the ask line explain it?
Why shorts get stopped out by a spread spike
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
-
FXS HongKong Scalper
- Posts: 545
- Joined: Sat Oct 24, 2026 10:15 pm
Re: Why shorts get stopped out by a spread spike
This one surprises a lot of people, and it is worst in exactly the thin hours: the rollover minutes and the Asia lull on some crosses. A short with a 3 pip stop on a pair whose spread can briefly reach 4 pips is a stop waiting for the spread, not for the market. Checking the maximum spread at the hour being traded, not the average, should decide the minimum stop.
FXS Official Team | Hong Kong Session Desk
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Why shorts get stopped out by a spread spike
I've had the bid chart look completely calm after a short was stopped, and checking the ask line explained it. On one thin-session trade, the ask briefly lifted through my stop while the bid barely moved; looking only at the candle made the fill seem impossible. I now keep both prices visible and review the quote history around the trigger before deciding whether it was spread expansion or a genuine price move.
A practical change was to compare the stop distance with the spread I actually see in that pair and session, rather than using the chart's usual candle range. If the spread can consume a meaningful part of the stop room, I either wait for the liquid window or skip the setup; widening a stop after entry just changes the risk without fixing the entry.
For review, I save the execution time, bid/ask, and spread around the trigger alongside the chart screenshot. That gives a much fairer comparison with the broker's stop rules. On the occasional hold through rollover, I avoid relying on a tight short stop alone to protect the position.
A practical change was to compare the stop distance with the spread I actually see in that pair and session, rather than using the chart's usual candle range. If the spread can consume a meaningful part of the stop room, I either wait for the liquid window or skip the setup; widening a stop after entry just changes the risk without fixing the entry.
For review, I save the execution time, bid/ask, and spread around the trigger alongside the chart screenshot. That gives a much fairer comparison with the broker's stop rules. On the occasional hold through rollover, I avoid relying on a tight short stop alone to protect the position.