Advertisement IC Markets

The Sunday gap fill myth

Real-time market analysis, live trade entries, order flow commentary, and daily setups for the London, New York, and Asian session overlaps.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

The Sunday gap fill myth

Post by Fairman »

The Sunday gap fill myth

Everybody has heard it: gaps always fill. A bit of searching shows it is rather less certain than the folklore suggests.

On major currency pairs, weekend gaps are usually small, a few pips at most. Plenty of them close within the first hours, mostly because the first quotes of the week are thin and wide, and the spread has more to do with the gap than any real price change.

On bigger gaps, those following a major weekend event, the move often continues instead of filling. The gap is not a hole in the chart but a repricing, and the market has no obligation to return to where it was.

Scalpers who trade the fill often get a handful of small wins and one large loss when a real gap fails to close. The maths seldom works out as neatly as the story suggests.

A better question is whether a gap came from a change in information or just a quirk of thin quotes. The first deserves respect. The second is mostly noise.

There is a version of the gap fill idea that does hold up: small gaps under about 10 pips in liquid pairs fill within a day more often than not. The reason is partly mechanical and partly that these gaps are mostly noise. The mistake is stretching that observation to gaps of 50 pips or more, where the cause is almost always real information.

A decent filter is looking at what happened over the weekend. If nothing in the news explains the gap, it probably reflects thin quoting and tends to fade. If the weekend contained an election, a central bank surprise, or a geopolitical event, the gap deserves respect, and fading it is a bet against new information.

Backtesting this on ten years of data shows a pattern most people do not expect: the average gap fill is quick for small gaps and slow for large ones, and the large gaps contain nearly all of the pain.

Has trading a gap fill ever gone badly wrong?
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
FXS HongKong Scalper
Posts: 543
Joined: Sat Oct 24, 2026 10:15 pm

Re: The Sunday gap fill myth

Post by FXS HongKong Scalper »

Fairman wrote: There is a version of the gap fill idea that does hold up: small gaps under about 10 pips in liquid pairs fill within a day more often than not.
Good to see this tested. Most weekend gaps on majors are small and close quickly, but the spread at the Sunday open often makes the trade cost more than it earns. The occasional large gap that does not fill is the one that does the damage.
FXS Official Team | Hong Kong Session Desk
Amanhasnoname
Posts: 2060
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am

Re: The Sunday gap fill myth

Post by Amanhasnoname »

Yes, and it cured me of the idea for good. A few years back I faded a Sunday open on GBPJPY that had opened noticeably lower after some weekend political headlines I had skimmed and decided were nothing. I went long expecting the usual drift back to Friday's close, sized it like a normal scalp, and watched it keep sliding through the Asian session. By the time Tokyo was properly open I had taken a loss bigger than the previous month of small gap wins put together.

What I do now is simpler. Before the open I write down Friday's close and read the weekend headlines for both currencies in the pair. If there is anything with real substance, I don't touch the gap at all and just wait for London to show me where price wants to be.

On the quiet weekends I still take the occasional small fill, but never in the first twenty minutes, because the spread at that hour eats most of the edge, exactly as the reply above says.
Shadow Trader
Posts: 5594
Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm

Re: The Sunday gap fill myth

Post by Shadow Trader »

Agree with this. The idea that gaps always fill is one of those things that gets repeated because the ones that do fill are memorable, while the ones that don't just quietly drop out of the conversation.

If you look at Sunday opens over a long stretch, small gaps on the majors fill fairly often within the first day, but the bigger gaps, the ones caused by actual weekend news, are much less reliable. Those are the ones where you'd be trading against a genuine change in information, and they're also the ones where the move after the open can keep going.

For scalping, I'd add that the first hour after the open is a terrible place to trade a gap fill anyway. Spreads are often several times their normal level, and the liquidity is thin enough that a stop can fill a long way from where you put it. Even if the gap does fill eventually, you can be stopped out on the way there.

If someone really wants to trade it, I'd suggest waiting until Tokyo is properly active, using a size small enough that a non-fill doesn't hurt much, and having a clear time limit. If it hasn't filled by the start of London, the reason for the trade is probably gone.
Post Reply