Advertisement IC Markets

Case Study, Mei: Trading the News and Missing the Stop

Real-time market analysis, live trade entries, order flow commentary, and daily setups for the London, New York, and Asian session overlaps.
Post Reply
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Case Study, Mei: Trading the News and Missing the Stop

Post by Fairman »

Case Study, Mei: Trading the News and Missing the Stop

Mei is a composite character. She trades the first minutes after major data, with a planned stop of 10 pips and a target of 20. Her records show that on news trades, her stops fill an average of 17 pips from entry, because of slippage and wide spreads. Her targets fill as planned, 20 pips, about 40 percent of the time.

Compute the plan versus reality. Planned: 0.4 times 20 minus 0.6 times 10, which is 8 minus 6, plus 2 pips per trade. Actual: 0.4 times 20 minus 0.6 times 17, which is 8 minus 10.2, minus 2.2 pips.

The slippage alone, 7 pips on each loser, turned a positive expectancy into a negative one. On 0.5 lots at 5 dollars per pip, the difference is 4.2 pips times 5, which is 21 dollars per trade.

Add the spread. On news, it may widen to 4 pips, which affects both sides. Her entry costs add another 4 pips against her. The result is much worse.

Possible fixes. Wait 5 to 15 minutes after the release, when spreads normalize, and trade the developing direction instead. Use smaller sizes, accepting that the stop may fill beyond its level. Use limit orders where possible. Or stop trading news.

What is the evidence for each? Track fills over 30 news trades and compare.

Lesson: planned risk and actual risk differ most when markets move fastest, and the strategy should be judged by actual fills.

Exercise: compute your average stop fill distance on the last ten stop-outs relative to plan.
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
FXS HongKong Scalper
Posts: 543
Joined: Sat Oct 24, 2026 10:15 pm

Re: Case Study, Mei: Trading the News and Missing the Stop

Post by FXS HongKong Scalper »

Fairman wrote: She trades the first minutes after major data, with a planned stop of 10 pips and a target of 20.
The 17 versus 10 pip gap tells the whole story. With a 20 pip target and 17 pip actual loss, the reward-to-risk is far worse than planned. Mei's fix might be to plan the trade with the real 17 pip loss and see if it still makes sense. If not, waiting a few minutes after the release, when spreads normalise, may suit her better.
FXS Official Team | Hong Kong Session Desk
Amanhasnoname
Posts: 2060
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am

Re: Case Study, Mei: Trading the News and Missing the Stop

Post by Amanhasnoname »

The 17 pip stop fill is very familiar. I used to trade the non-farm payrolls release with an 8 pip stop and found that my average exit on losers was closer to 14 pips, with a couple of 20 pip fills when the broker re-quoted. Once I put real numbers into a spreadsheet, the strategy that looked like a modest winner on paper turned out to be a slow bleed.

What fixed it for me was changing what I measure. I stopped logging the planned stop and logged only the fill price, then calculated expectancy from fills across 25 news trades. That sample was ugly enough that I stopped entering in the first minute altogether. I now wait until the spread is back within a pip of normal, usually around ten minutes, and trade the first pullback with a stop sized from the actual post-release range.

The trade-off is that I miss the very first burst, and some days the best move is already done. But my stop fills now land within two pips of the plan, and that predictability is worth more to me than the occasional fast winner. If Mei insists on trading the spike, limit orders and half size are the least painful compromise I have found.
Post Reply