Take a scalp with a two pip target on a major. On a standard account the spread might average around one pip with no commission. On a raw account the spread might sit near zero to a tenth of a pip, with a commission charged per lot per side. The numbers vary by broker, so treat these as an illustration, not a quote.
On the standard account the cost is inside the spread and easy to see on the chart. On the raw account the cost is split, and the commission usually shows up only in the statement. Judging the raw account by the spread alone looks like a free lunch. Adding the commission in pips shows that the real gap is often small, and it can go either way depending on the hour.
Here is where it hides. Commission is flat, while the spread is not. During quiet hours the raw account can be cheaper. During news or rollover both widen, but the standard account's markup widens with it, while the raw commission stays put, so in general terms the raw option tends to look better when conditions are rough.
The other hiding spot is round turn versus per side. A commission quoted per side is doubled on a full trade, and plenty of people mentally compare one side of the commission against a full spread.
The cleanest way to compare is to convert everything to pips per round turn, using the same trade times, and compare the totals instead of the headline numbers.
When raw and standard accounts were compared on the same pair, which one came out cheaper for the hours you actually trade?
Raw-spread account or standard account: where the extra cost ends up
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1690
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Raw-spread account or standard account: where the extra cost ends up
With a two pip target, the difference between the account types matters a lot. A simple calculation of total cost per trade on each account, including commission, shows which suits a given trading style.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Raw-spread account or standard account: where the extra cost ends up
I used to think the raw account was automatically cheaper because the quote looked almost costless on my screen. On EURGBP during the London morning, my statement showed a different story: the commission was manageable, but the spread briefly widened around the fix and turned a small target into a near break-even trade. I started comparing round-trip costs from my actual fills rather than the advertised minimum.
Now I export a few weeks of tickets and convert spread, both commission sides, and any swap into the same currency per trade. I split the sample by hour and include the losing fills; otherwise the quiet-hour average makes the account look better than it behaves when I actually trade. On days when my order size changed, I kept those out of the comparison so the cost difference was not muddied by different fills.
For my style the raw account wins in liquid stretches, but not by enough to ignore execution quality. I would compare the median and the ugly tail for the precise sessions you trade, then keep the account whose all-in cost leaves room for your target.
Now I export a few weeks of tickets and convert spread, both commission sides, and any swap into the same currency per trade. I split the sample by hour and include the losing fills; otherwise the quiet-hour average makes the account look better than it behaves when I actually trade. On days when my order size changed, I kept those out of the comparison so the cost difference was not muddied by different fills.
For my style the raw account wins in liquid stretches, but not by enough to ignore execution quality. I would compare the median and the ugly tail for the precise sessions you trade, then keep the account whose all-in cost leaves room for your target.