Advertisement IC Markets

WHAT LOOKS LIKE EDGE BUT ISN'T

Document your personal trading journey. Track daily equity curves, review winning and losing streaks, share trade screenshots, and get constructive feedback.
Fairman
Posts: 6955
Joined: Tue Jul 21, 2026 7:11 am
Location: Abuja

Re: WHAT LOOKS LIKE EDGE BUT ISN'T

Post by Fairman »

Fake edge being storytelling with a chart is the line I'd pin. The filter questions are what I run too, and the second one, whether the parameters were stable before the curve looked pretty, catches the most. I tested a moving average cross last year and found a 20 period setting with a profit factor of 1.6. Moving it to 19 or 21 dropped it under 1.1. That wasn't edge, it was a lucky parameter.

The range-weeks test is a good one. A method that only appears in trend screenshots is really a trend detector, and trends are visible in hindsight on any chart. If it makes 4R in a trending fortnight and loses 3R through two choppy ones, the total is +1R across a month, and with spread at 0.6 pips on every entry I'd expect that to be a negative result in practice.

Freezing the rules for a fixed sample is where I struggle. I want to tweak after ten trades. Setting a rule like "no changes until 100 trades" would stop me, and I'd put the date in the journal so I can't pretend it was shorter.

The point on fat left tails is easy to miss as well. A 75 percent win rate with a loss six times the size of the average win has an expectancy of roughly -0.5R if that loss comes once in four trades.

Do you pick the freeze sample size by setup frequency, or a flat number? And what do you do when the results look best right at the end of the freeze?
It’s Fairman :geek:
Recommended broker for automated trading & scalping IC Markets
gwhitlock64
Posts: 60
Joined: Tue Oct 20, 2026 11:01 pm

Re: WHAT LOOKS LIKE EDGE BUT ISN'T

Post by gwhitlock64 »

Fairman wrote:Do you pick the freeze sample size by setup frequency, or a flat number? And what do you do when the results look best right at the end of the freeze?
Fairman, I'd go with a flat number myself, something like 50-100 trades minimum, otherwise low frequency setups never get a fair test ta. If results look best right at the end of the freeze that's usually just recency bias talking, I'd keep going another full cycle before trusting it, saved me from a dodgy breakout system that looked proper lush for exactly 3 weeks then fell apart.
Post Reply