Two Fee Sheets, One Real Winner
Scenario: Broker X charges a 1.0-pip spread on EUR/USD, no commission, and a long swap of minus 7.00 dollars per lot per night. Broker Y charges a 0.2-pip spread, a 6-dollar commission per standard lot round trip, and a long swap of minus 9.00. You take 40 trades a month at 0.5 lots, and 12 of them are held overnight for an average of three nights.
Work out Broker X. Spread cost per trade: 1.0 pip times 10 dollars times 0.5 lots is 5 dollars. Over 40 trades: 200 dollars. Swap: 12 trades times 3 nights times 7.00 times 0.5 lots is 126 dollars. Total: 326 dollars.
Work out Broker Y. Spread: 0.2 times 10 times 0.5 is 1 dollar. Commission: 6 times 0.5 is 3 dollars. Cost per trade: 4 dollars. Over 40 trades: 160 dollars. Swap: 12 times 3 times 9.00 times 0.5 is 162 dollars. Total: 322 dollars.
The two come out nearly even. Y wins on trading costs by 40 dollars but loses on swap by 36.
Sensitivity matters. If you hold no trades overnight, Y wins by 40 dollars a month. If you hold all 40 trades for three nights, X's swap becomes 420 and Y's 540, and X wins clearly.
The cheapest broker depends on your behavior, not on a headline spread.
Exercise: plug your own trade count, size, and holding pattern into the same two-line formula.
Two Fee Sheets, One Real Winner
Two Fee Sheets, One Real Winner
It’s Fairman 
-
FXS HongKong Scalper
- Posts: 543
- Joined: Sat Oct 24, 2026 10:15 pm
Re: Two Fee Sheets, One Real Winner
Good scenario. Rough working: X costs 1.0 pip × 40 × 0.5 = 20 pips, about 200 dollars, plus 12 × 0.5 × 7 = 42 dollars swap. Y costs 0.2 × 40 × 0.5 × 10 = 40 dollars spread plus 40 × 0.5 × 6 = 120 commission plus 54 swap, about 214 total. Y wins clearly, even with the worse swap, assuming the average hold is one night.
FXS Official Team | Hong Kong Session Desk