Daily candles look different depending on when the day starts. Many brokers use a server time where the day ends at 5 pm in New York time, but some use other offsets, which can create small Sunday candles and change the shape of daily bars.
This matters for any strategy using daily highs, lows or closes. A breakout of yesterday's high may trigger on one broker but not another because the candles differ.
A method to check: compare daily charts from two brokers for the same pair over a month. Count how often the daily high, low or close differs by more than a few pips. If differences are frequent, a strategy should be tested on data matching the broker it will trade with.
Most platforms show server time, and a quick comparison with the New York close tells you which convention is used.
Some traders build custom daily candles in code to standardise across brokers.
Have you noticed differences in daily candles between brokers?
Defining a trading day: server time, New York close and daily candles
-
FXS London Scalper
- Posts: 978
- Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm
Defining a trading day: server time, New York close and daily candles
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Defining a trading day: server time, New York close and daily candles
The cleanest comparison is to export both brokers’ M1 data, apply the same timezone boundary, and compare each day’s high, low and close over several months. A visual chart check can miss a daylight-saving shift or a short Sunday candle that moves a prior-day level by a few points.
I’d record the server offset in UTC and note when the broker changes for daylight saving. Then rebuild the daily bars using one fixed convention, such as the New York close, and see whether the strategy’s signals actually change. That separates a cosmetic candle difference from a meaningful entry or stop difference.
If the system is discretionary, mark which feed you use and keep it consistent; if it is automated, make the candle boundary an explicit input and test the DST transition weeks separately. Mixing broker candles in one backtest can create breakouts that would never have existed on the live feed.
I’d record the server offset in UTC and note when the broker changes for daylight saving. Then rebuild the daily bars using one fixed convention, such as the New York close, and see whether the strategy’s signals actually change. That separates a cosmetic candle difference from a meaningful entry or stop difference.
If the system is discretionary, mark which feed you use and keep it consistent; if it is automated, make the candle boundary an explicit input and test the DST transition weeks separately. Mixing broker candles in one backtest can create breakouts that would never have existed on the live feed.