IB rebates and the incentives hiding behind friendly reviews
A site reviews brokers and recommends one. The site earns a share of the commission or spread for every trade the referred client makes. The recommendation is not necessarily wrong, but the incentive is worth knowing.
Introducing brokers and affiliates are paid per lot, which creates a bias toward brokers that pay well and toward traders who trade a lot, a description that fits scalpers perfectly.
Some rebates are returned to the client, which can be a real benefit. A rebate of a dollar or two per lot reduces the cost of every trade and can tilt a marginal strategy into profit.
It pays to ask how the rebate works, how often it is paid, whether it is reduced when volume is high, and whether it affects the execution or conditions on the account.
It also pays to read reviews with the money trail in mind. A glowing review from a site that earns a fee is a different kind of evidence than a list of customer withdrawal experiences on an independent forum.
Some traders also ask the broker directly how much of the spread or commission is shared with the introducer. Honest answers are rare, but the question itself is revealing.
What do rebates change in the cost per trade, and who is on the other end of the referral link?
IB rebates and the incentives hiding behind friendly reviews
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: IB rebates and the incentives hiding behind friendly reviews
I took a rebate deal through an introducer about two years ago, and it did lower my costs in a real way. The rebate came to a little under two dollars per round-turn lot, paid weekly, and on the volume I was doing that worked out to roughly a fifth of my total commission. For a scalping account that is not small, and it turned a couple of flat months into slightly positive ones.
What I had not asked was whether the account was set up the same way as a direct one. After a while I opened a second, direct account with the same broker and ran the same pair side by side on small size. Slippage on market orders during busy minutes was noticeably worse on the rebate account, enough to eat most of the rebate on news days.
I still think rebates can be worth having, but I compare the full cost now, including fills, rather than just the cash that comes back. And I read any review on a site with a referral link knowing the writer gets paid every time I trade.
What I had not asked was whether the account was set up the same way as a direct one. After a while I opened a second, direct account with the same broker and ran the same pair side by side on small size. Slippage on market orders during busy minutes was noticeably worse on the rebate account, enough to eat most of the rebate on news days.
I still think rebates can be worth having, but I compare the full cost now, including fills, rather than just the cash that comes back. And I read any review on a site with a referral link knowing the writer gets paid every time I trade.