Tight stops mean more trades, and more trades mean more spread
A tighter stop looks like better risk control. It also changes the rate at which trades get stopped and replaced.
Each new trade costs a spread. A strategy that uses a 3 pip stop and gets stopped out often will generate many more trades than one with a 10 pip stop, and the cumulative cost of spread and commission rises with it.
A short example: a strategy with 100 trades per day and a cost of 0.8 pips per trade pays 80 pips daily just to participate. If the average edge per trade is below 0.8, the result is a steady loss, hidden by the volume.
That is why many scalpers who tighten stops see their results get worse, even if each loss is smaller. The frequency of losses increases, and the costs accumulate.
The test is measuring net expectancy per trade after costs for different stop sizes. The optimum is often wider than expected.
A neat chart is net expectancy per trade against stop size, drawn from the log. It usually forms a hump, and the top of the hump is not at the tightest setting.
Has tightening a stop ever made the results worse instead of better?
Tight stops mean more trades, and more trades mean more spread
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Tight stops mean more trades, and more trades mean more spread
Yes, and it took me far too long to see it. I spent a stretch scalping EURJPY with a four-pip stop because the losses looked so small on the statement. The trouble was that I was getting stopped and re-entering constantly, often on the same idea, and I was averaging something like sixty round trips a day. At around a pip all in, the costs were swallowing almost everything the entries earned.
I went back through three months of the log and replayed the same entries with stops of four, six, eight, ten and twelve pips. Gross results improved steadily up to about nine pips, and once costs were taken off, net expectancy per trade peaked there too. The hump the original post mentions showed up almost exactly, and four pips sat right at the bottom of it.
I now use a stop around nine pips on that pair with size cut to keep the money risk the same. I take far fewer trades, the cost line on the statement shrank by more than half, and I am no longer paying the spread just to be shaken out.
I went back through three months of the log and replayed the same entries with stops of four, six, eight, ten and twelve pips. Gross results improved steadily up to about nine pips, and once costs were taken off, net expectancy per trade peaked there too. The hump the original post mentions showed up almost exactly, and four pips sat right at the bottom of it.
I now use a stop around nine pips on that pair with size cut to keep the money risk the same. I take far fewer trades, the cost line on the statement shrank by more than half, and I am no longer paying the spread just to be shaken out.