Why straddles around news usually fail
The idea sounds smart: place a buy stop above and a sell stop below the price a minute before the release, and catch the move in whichever direction it goes. An OCO setup, one cancels the other.
Reality is less kind. Spreads widen before the news, so the pending orders sit near a market that is moving against them. Orders can trigger on the spread alone. Price spikes through one side, fills at a poor price, then reverses and hits the other side, resulting in two losses.
There is also the matter of slippage. Stop orders become market orders at the trigger, and in a thin, fast market they fill far from the intended level. The trade starts with a deficit before anything has happened.
Brokers also sometimes widen the minimum distance for pending orders during news, so the orders cannot be placed where intended.
Traders who still use straddles tend to place them wide, use small size, and accept that a lot of attempts will lose. The ones who succeed usually have a very specific edge in a particular release and have measured it thoroughly.
A more sensible variant is placing a single pending order after the first spike settles, in the direction of the post-spike drift, with a stop beyond the extreme of the move. It removes the double loss scenario and the worst of the slippage.
What happened the last time a straddle was tried around a major release?
Why straddles around news usually fail
Why straddles around news usually fail
It’s Fairman 
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Why straddles around news usually fail
I tried a buy-stop and sell-stop straddle on a US CPI release, eight pips either side of the last price, about a minute before the print. The spread went from three tenths to about three point eight pips, the buy stop filled roughly nine pips through the trigger, and then price snapped back and took the sell stop as well. Both sides were stopped out. The book showed minus two point two R in under a minute.
The broker had also raised the minimum distance for pending orders to twelve pips just before the number, so I was already wider than I had planned. That detail is easy to miss if you place the orders early and never look again. Combined with the slippage, the trade was lost on the fill quality rather than on a wrong view of direction.
I do not straddle releases now. If I trade one at all I wait until the first spike has printed and the spread has come back in, then I take only one side, with the stop beyond that extreme. It is slower, but I have not repeated the double loss.
The broker had also raised the minimum distance for pending orders to twelve pips just before the number, so I was already wider than I had planned. That detail is easy to miss if you place the orders early and never look again. Combined with the slippage, the trade was lost on the fill quality rather than on a wrong view of direction.
I do not straddle releases now. If I trade one at all I wait until the first spike has printed and the spread has come back in, then I take only one side, with the stop beyond that extreme. It is slower, but I have not repeated the double loss.