Platform spread display versus actual fill spread
The spread shown on the screen is the difference between the best bid and the best ask at that moment. The cost of a trade depends on the actual fill prices, which may differ when orders are large or when the market is moving.
On ECN accounts with depth, the effective spread for a larger order is wider than the top-of-book spread, since part of the order fills at deeper levels. On accounts with markups applied at execution rather than in the quote, the screen spread may omit them entirely.
To find out, compare the fill prices of a buy and a sell executed close together. The difference is the realized round-trip cost. Repeat several times and average.
If the realized cost is consistently higher than the displayed spread plus commission, something is being added: slippage, markup, or delay.
This simple measurement gives a truer cost baseline than any marketing material. It also helps in comparing different brokers on equal terms.
How does the realized round-trip cost compare to the quoted spread on the account in use?
Platform spread display versus actual fill spread
Platform spread display versus actual fill spread
It’s Fairman 
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Platform spread display versus actual fill spread
I started pairing a market buy with a market sell a few seconds later just to see what the round trip really cost. I did this forty times on EURUSD during ordinary London hours, twenty passes at two tenths of a lot and twenty at a full lot, always when the platform showed about twenty-four hundredths of a pip. At the smaller size the realized round trip averaged thirty-one hundredths. At the full lot it averaged forty-eight.
The extra seven hundredths on the small clips was not depth. It was the book moving while the order travelled, plus the occasional partial that refreshed a tick worse. The jump at the larger size was depth: the second half of the clip regularly printed beyond the top of the book even though the screen still showed a tight quote.
I now treat displayed spread plus commission as a lower bound, not the cost I actually pay. For live sizing I assume about half a pip round trip on a standard lot in London, and I skip the trade if that figure would wipe most of the target.
The extra seven hundredths on the small clips was not depth. It was the book moving while the order travelled, plus the occasional partial that refreshed a tick worse. The jump at the larger size was depth: the second half of the clip regularly printed beyond the top of the book even though the screen still showed a tight quote.
I now treat displayed spread plus commission as a lower bound, not the cost I actually pay. For live sizing I assume about half a pip round trip on a standard lot in London, and I skip the trade if that figure would wipe most of the target.
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1689
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Platform spread display versus actual fill spread
The effective spread on larger orders is worth measuring directly: filled price minus mid at the time of the order. Comparing it by order size shows where the displayed spread stops being accurate, which matters for anyone scaling up on a funded account.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy