Why the trade right after a big win is usually the worst one
A big winner produces a rush that bends judgment. Confidence climbs, risk perception drops, and the next setup gets less scrutiny. Size creeps up, filters loosen, and the trade taken in this state tends to be lower quality than average.
It is easy to confirm in the data. Sort trades by the result of the preceding trade, and compare expectancy after a large win with expectancy after a normal outcome. Many traders see a clear dip.
The reverse also happens after a big loss, but that effect gets more attention. The post-win slump is harder to notice because the account is up and nothing feels wrong.
A practical countermeasure is a short forced pause after any trade above a certain size, either way. One or two minutes away from the screen, a glass of water, and a re-read of the rules before the next entry.
Another is a rule that the next trade after a big win must be at standard size, no exceptions.
Has the post-win trade been analyzed separately in your journal?
Why the trade right after a big win is usually the worst one
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Why the trade right after a big win is usually the worst one
I sorted six hundred and forty live trades by what the previous one had done. After a winner larger than one point two R, the next trade's expectancy was about minus zero point one eight R across seventy-one cases. After an ordinary scratch or small win it was plus zero point one one R. The trade after a large loss was only slightly worse than average, which surprised me because that is the one I had been watching.
The notes pointed at size more than at the setup. On twenty-four of those seventy-one post-win trades I had nudged the lot higher because things were working, and filters I normally wait for got a pass. The ideas themselves were not terrible. I was just sloppier.
I now take a three-minute break after any trade over one R, win or loss, and the expert locks the next order at standard size. The dip has flattened over the last two months, which is good enough.
The notes pointed at size more than at the setup. On twenty-four of those seventy-one post-win trades I had nudged the lot higher because things were working, and filters I normally wait for got a pass. The ideas themselves were not terrible. I was just sloppier.
I now take a three-minute break after any trade over one R, win or loss, and the expert locks the next order at standard size. The dip has flattened over the last two months, which is good enough.