Daily candle open and the strange behavior of spreads at the new day
The daily bar opens at 17:00 New York on most platforms, which coincides with rollover. But brokers use different server times, so on some platforms the new day begins at midnight server time, and on others it begins when Sydney opens.
Strategies referencing the daily open, daily high and low, or daily pivots can behave differently from one broker to the next. A level that matters on one platform sits somewhere else on another.
Spreads and quote stability around the daily open vary as well, because some brokers settle accounts and recalculate overnight positions at that moment. Execution during these minutes tends to be poor.
For consistent results, define the day yourself, such as 22:00 UTC to 22:00 UTC, and compute levels from tick or minute data accordingly. That removes dependence on the broker's candle boundaries.
When comparing backtests across brokers or data vendors, check that daily bars are aligned. A mismatch of even an hour can alter highs and lows and change which trades are taken.
What day boundary does the system use, and was it ever mismatched against the data?
Daily candle open and the strange behavior of spreads at the new day
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Daily candle open and the strange behavior of spreads at the new day
I lost a week of backtests to the daily open without noticing. One data vendor started the daily bar at five o'clock New York and another at midnight server time, which was twenty-two hundred UTC on that feed. The daily high sat in a different place on twenty-three of sixty-two days, and a pivot fade I was testing took nine extra trades on one set that the other never saw.
Live trading taught the same lesson around rollover. On my broker the spread regularly jumped from three tenths of a pip to somewhere between four and nine pips for twenty to forty seconds after the five o'clock stamp. Two stops I had left nearby were filled several pips through the level during that window.
I now compute my own day from twenty-two hundred UTC on minute data, and I flatten or widen stops a few minutes before rollover. Comparing systems across brokers without lining up that boundary has been a waste of time for me.
Live trading taught the same lesson around rollover. On my broker the spread regularly jumped from three tenths of a pip to somewhere between four and nine pips for twenty to forty seconds after the five o'clock stamp. Two stops I had left nearby were filled several pips through the level during that window.
I now compute my own day from twenty-two hundred UTC on minute data, and I flatten or widen stops a few minutes before rollover. Comparing systems across brokers without lining up that boundary has been a waste of time for me.
-
FXS London Scalper
- Posts: 976
- Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2026 12:25 pm
Re: Daily candle open and the strange behavior of spreads at the new day
This bites anyone using daily pivots or yesterday's high and low. A broker on GMT server time builds a small Sunday candle and a different Monday daily bar than one on New York close time, so "yesterday's high" can be a different number on two platforms. Checking the server time once and choosing the chart that matches New York close avoids a lot of confusion.
FXS Official Team | London Session Desk