Commission plus raw spread is not always cheaper than a wide-spread account
Marketing for raw spread accounts shows 0.1 pip on EUR/USD and a flat commission, and the total looks like a bargain compared to a standard account. For some scalpers it is. For others the math tells a different story.
The real cost is commission per round turn plus the actual average spread during the exact minutes traded, not the headline minimum. A pair that averages 0.1 in the London session might sit at 0.6 during the Asian window. Add commission, and a Tokyo-session scalper may pay more than on a plain zero-commission account with a steady 1.0 spread.
The reverse also happens. Standard accounts sometimes widen far more during volatility, since the markup is baked into the spread.
The only reliable way to compare is pulling actual tick spread data from each account for the traded hours, then calculating total cost per lot in dollars rather than pips.
It takes an afternoon in a spreadsheet and can save thousands a year.
Has anyone compared two account types side by side with real tick data, and which one won?
Commission plus raw spread is not always cheaper than a wide-spread account
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Commission plus raw spread is not always cheaper than a wide-spread account
I logged every quote on the same EURUSD London hours for three weeks, once on a raw account and once on a standard one. The raw book showed a median spread of sixteen hundredths of a pip in the morning, plus a seven dollar round-turn commission, which came to about sixty-two hundredths of a pip all-in on a standard lot. The standard account sat near eighty-five hundredths with no commission.
Tokyo flipped the comparison. The raw spread widened to about fifty-five hundredths and the commission still applied, so all-in cost ran near one pip. The standard account stayed around ninety-two hundredths. Because most of my size is in London, the raw account still won overall by roughly a quarter of a pip per round turn.
The standard book also blew out more on news, once to four pips while the raw side only went to one point six plus the commission. I kept the raw account for the hours I actually trade and I no longer bother comparing them session by session.
Tokyo flipped the comparison. The raw spread widened to about fifty-five hundredths and the commission still applied, so all-in cost ran near one pip. The standard account stayed around ninety-two hundredths. Because most of my size is in London, the raw account still won overall by roughly a quarter of a pip per round turn.
The standard book also blew out more on news, once to four pips while the raw side only went to one point six plus the commission. I kept the raw account for the hours I actually trade and I no longer bother comparing them session by session.