Order size changes the fill: test with one lot versus ten
A scalper who tests a strategy on 0.1 lots and then scales to 5 lots is often shocked by how different the results feel. The strategy did not change, but the execution did.
Small orders typically fill from the top of the book at the quoted price. Larger orders chew through multiple levels. Some brokers also route small and large tickets differently, with bigger tickets getting extra checks or a longer hold time.
The practical test is straightforward. Run the same strategy during the same session with several sizes, perhaps 0.1, 1, and 5 lots, and compare average slippage and fill latency across them. The relationship is rarely linear. There is often a threshold, something like three lots, past which cost climbs quickly.
Knowing that threshold gives a real capacity limit for the system. Beyond it, either split orders across time, spread across multiple accounts, or accept lower returns per trade.
Better to find the ceiling in testing than during a live drawdown.
Where did the cost curve bend sharply on your account, and at what size?
Order size changes the fill: test with one lot versus ten
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Order size changes the fill: test with one lot versus ten
The jump from a quarter lot to two lots taught me more about my broker than any of the strategy tests. I ran the same EURUSD signals through eight London sessions at zero point zero two, zero point two five, zero point eight zero, and two point zero zero lots. Slippage averaged thirteen hundredths of a pip at the smallest size and sixteen at a quarter lot, so those two felt the same. At point eight it jumped to thirty-one hundredths, and at two lots it was seventy-four hundredths with partial fills on about one trade in five.
The cost curve bent near seven tenths of a lot on that account. Below that I was still taking liquidity from the top of the book. Above it I was walking the book and, I suspect, getting a slower route.
I now cap a single ticket at six tenths and split anything larger across a short delay rather than dumping it at once. Finding that ceiling on purpose was cheaper than discovering it in the middle of a live drawdown.
The cost curve bent near seven tenths of a lot on that account. Below that I was still taking liquidity from the top of the book. Above it I was walking the book and, I suspect, getting a slower route.
I now cap a single ticket at six tenths and split anything larger across a short delay rather than dumping it at once. Finding that ceiling on purpose was cheaper than discovering it in the middle of a live drawdown.