Target fixation: holding for the extra pip
A trade is up three pips with a four-pip target. The scalper watches as price stalls, then slips back. The final pip seems so close that exiting early feels like giving up. Then the trade reverses and ends at a loss.
Fixation on the original target ignores new information. As price approaches, the probability of reaching the target changes, and the remaining expected gain may be lower than the risk of giving back profit.
A systematic approach examines the data: for trades that reached 75 percent of the target, what fraction went on to hit the full target? If it is, say, 55 percent, and the stop is wide, then holding may or may not be worth it.
Some scalpers use partial exits, closing most of the position near the target and leaving a small amount to run. Others adjust the target based on volatility.
Whatever the rule, it should be based on the observed distribution, not on the feeling of being so close.
What proportion of trades that get within a pip of the target end up reaching it?
Target fixation: holding for the extra pip
Target fixation: holding for the extra pip
It’s Fairman 
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Target fixation: holding for the extra pip
Pride kept me holding USDCHF for the last pip longer than the numbers supported. I use an eight-pip objective, and over twelve weeks one hundred and four trades got within one pip of that plan. Fifty-eight of them, about fifty-six percent, went on to tag the full eight. The other forty-six gave back an average of two point eight pips from that point, often sliding to scratch or a small loss.
The arithmetic is ugly if you hold for that last pip as a rule. Fifty-eight times one pip minus forty-six times two point eight is a net giveback, so the extra pip was not earning its risk on my numbers. Feeling so close was a terrible reason to stay.
I now close seventy-five percent of the position at seven pips and leave a quarter to run toward eight or a bit beyond. Across the next thirty-nine trades that rule added roughly zero point three five pips per trade compared with the old all-or-nothing hold. The original target is a plan, not a promise.
The arithmetic is ugly if you hold for that last pip as a rule. Fifty-eight times one pip minus forty-six times two point eight is a net giveback, so the extra pip was not earning its risk on my numbers. Feeling so close was a terrible reason to stay.
I now close seventy-five percent of the position at seven pips and leave a quarter to run toward eight or a bit beyond. Across the next thirty-nine trades that rule added roughly zero point three five pips per trade compared with the old all-or-nothing hold. The original target is a plan, not a promise.