A partial fill on a market order feels like it should be rare, and then it shows up at rollover or in the first seconds after a news release and suddenly a position is half the size that was requested. The order did not fail. It found only part of the volume at an acceptable price, and the rest was either cancelled or left hanging, depending on the fill policy the server uses.
The detail people tend to skip is that the remainder matters as much as the part that filled. Fill or kill, immediate or cancel and return behave very differently. Under return, the leftover can sit as a working order and fill later at a price nobody wanted. Under immediate or cancel, the remainder just disappears, and the position ends up smaller than the stop and target were designed for.
Thin moments are also when a small lot gets assumed to be safe. Size is not the only factor. Depth at the top of the book can be tiny even for a size that looks trivial.
What is worth checking is the fill policy listed in the symbol specifications, since it sits in plain sight and rarely gets read.
Which fill policy does your broker use on the pairs you scalp, and have you ever caught a partial fill on a position under a few lots?
Partial fills on market orders in thin markets
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
-
FXS Prop Desk
- Posts: 1691
- Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 9:52 am
Re: Partial fills on market orders in thin markets
A half-size fill at rollover is a risk problem in both directions: the stop is sized for a full position and the target for a full reward. Checking volume in the trade tab after every fill during thin periods, and deciding by rule whether to top up or leave it, keeps exposure where the plan put it. Partial fills that hang as pending orders are worth cancelling explicitly.
FXS Official Team | The Idea Lab & Strategy
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Partial fills on market orders in thin markets
I got caught by this on a two lot USDCHF order a few seconds after rollover. The platform showed I was only filled for 1.3 lots, and since my stop and target were placed based on the full size, my risk to reward was quietly off for that trade. I only noticed because the profit figure looked smaller than expected when the target hit.
After that I opened the symbol specification on every pair I trade and checked the filling mode. My broker uses immediate or cancel on most majors, so the remainder just disappears, which I actually prefer to having a stray order fill later. On one exotic pair it was set to return, so I stopped trading that one around rollover entirely.
My rule now is simple. During rollover and the first minute after big data, I glance at the volume column after every fill. If it is short, I do not top it up. I just adjust the target in my head and treat it as a smaller trade.
After that I opened the symbol specification on every pair I trade and checked the filling mode. My broker uses immediate or cancel on most majors, so the remainder just disappears, which I actually prefer to having a stray order fill later. On one exotic pair it was set to return, so I stopped trading that one around rollover entirely.
My rule now is simple. During rollover and the first minute after big data, I glance at the volume column after every fill. If it is short, I do not top it up. I just adjust the target in my head and treat it as a smaller trade.