Scalpers talk in pips. "Made twelve pips this morning." The currency of the conversation hides the actual money, and that creates a psychological disconnect.
A trader who sees +8 pips feels good. If the position was a tenth of a lot, that's eight dollars. At ten lots, it's eight hundred. The same pips can be trivial or life-altering, and the emotional response follows the number on the screen, not the size of the account.
This matters most when position size changes. A trader who increases lot size after a streak keeps thinking in pips while the money risked quietly multiplies. A normal stop-out now costs a big chunk of the account, and the reaction is out of proportion to the pip count.
Another effect appears with spreads and commissions. Counting pips gross of costs inflates results. A net figure, converted to currency and divided by risk, tells the real story.
Journals that log both pips and money, plus the risk in money terms, reduce the confusion. Looking at results in terms of R multiples, the multiple of initial risk, puts everything on one scale.
Which unit gets used for review, and has that ever hidden a problem?
Pips don't pay rent, and the unit trap
-
Shadow Trader
- Posts: 5594
- Joined: Wed Sep 09, 2026 5:19 pm
-
FXS HongKong Scalper
- Posts: 548
- Joined: Sat Oct 24, 2026 10:15 pm
Re: Pips don't pay rent, and the unit trap
The unit trap is very real. Converting each result into account percentage in the journal fixes it in one column. Eight pips at 0.1 lots on a small account and at ten lots on a large one may both be 0.4% of the account, which is the number that should drive feelings, if anything should.
FXS Official Team | Hong Kong Session Desk
-
Amanhasnoname
- Posts: 2060
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 9:45 am
Re: Pips don't pay rent, and the unit trap
For a long time my journal only logged pips, and I felt great about mornings that finished plus ten. Then I grew the account and traded half a lot instead of a micro, and those same ten pips suddenly moved the balance enough to make me tense while the screen still said plus ten.
I fixed it by adding dollars made or lost and percent of account risked. After a few weeks the pip column stopped driving my mood. An eight-pip winner at different sizes shows as roughly the same account fraction when size is set by risk, and that is the figure I review first.
Spreads and commission go in the money column too. Once I converted everything to R multiples, small pip wins that barely covered costs stopped looking like progress. The unit trap faded the day the journal forced me to see the cash.
I fixed it by adding dollars made or lost and percent of account risked. After a few weeks the pip column stopped driving my mood. An eight-pip winner at different sizes shows as roughly the same account fraction when size is set by risk, and that is the figure I review first.
Spreads and commission go in the money column too. Once I converted everything to R multiples, small pip wins that barely covered costs stopped looking like progress. The unit trap faded the day the journal forced me to see the cash.